Lesson 8: Culture and perception
Evaluate de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018)
SkillsCulture and perceptionDesigning perception researchAnalysing perception data
Worked example
In de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018), 46 asylum seekers from Sub-Saharan Africa and 46 Dutch participants matched on gender, rural or urban background and age completed an adapted Hudson depth test (maximum 17). The African group scored , ; the European group , . The European group had more education, so education was controlled statistically.
(a) Calculate the standard error of the mean for each group. (b) Explain what the difference in standard deviations shows. (c) Evaluate the conclusion that "culture affects the perception of depth in pictures".
Step 1: Standard errors
African group: . European group: .
Step 2: Interpret the spread
Most European participants scored at or near the maximum (a ceiling effect), so their scores varied little. The African group's scores varied widely: some scored like the European group and others gave mostly 2D answers, so the group is far from uniform.
The authors looked for what explained the spread. Participants who had owned a television or computer scored higher on average (8.38 against 5.25), but with only 12 who had never owned a screen the difference was not significant (p = 0.091).
Step 3: Strengths
Matching on gender, background and age, and statistically controlling education, reduce confounding variables. It replicated Hudson's (1960) finding with a modern sample and a control group.
Step 4: Limitations
It is a quasi-experiment: culture was not randomly allocated, and education could not be matched, so other differences (schooling, familiarity with tests, asylum stress, testing through interpreters) could explain the gap. The test materials come from one culture's drawing conventions. Small subgroups (only 12 had never owned a screen) give low power.
Step 5: Judgement
The evidence supports a difference in pictorial depth perception linked to experience with pictures, but not that culture itself causes it, and the same study found no difference in recognising real objects.
Answer
(a) 0.81 and 0.37. (b) The European group was near the ceiling; the African group varied widely. (c) Well-controlled replication of a large difference, but as a quasi-experiment with unmatched education and culturally specific test materials it cannot show that culture causes the difference; it supports an influence of experience with pictures on pictorial depth perception.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
.
Evaluate with strengths, limitations of the design, and a judgement.
Watch out for
Concluding that people from Sub-Saharan Africa cannot perceive depth: the test measured depth in drawings only.
Using in the standard error: .