Lesson 3: Little Albert, learned fear and the ethics of early conditioning
Analyse a study of conditioned immune responses
SkillsLittle Albert and learned fearLearning research and data
Worked example
In Goebel et al. (2002), healthy volunteers took the immunosuppressant drug cyclosporin A together with a distinctively flavoured and coloured drink, four times over three days. The next week, the experimental group drank the same drink with placebo capsules, while a control group had not had the drink paired with the drug. The experimental group's immune function was suppressed after the drink alone. The study was double-blind and placebo-controlled.
(a) Identify the UCS, UCR, CS and CR. (b) Explain the purpose of the placebo capsules and of the double-blind procedure. (c) Evaluate how far this evidence supports classical conditioning of immune responses in humans.
Step 1: Identify the terms
UCS: cyclosporin A, which suppresses immune function without learning (the UCR). The drink was a NS; after pairing it became the CS, and immune suppression after the drink alone is the CR.
Step 2: Explain the placebo
At test, the volunteers took capsules that looked like the drug but contained none. This kept the procedure the same as in conditioning, so the drink could be tested on its own: any suppression could not be the drug's.
Step 3: Explain the double-blind procedure
Neither the volunteers nor the researchers who measured them knew who had the drug and who had the placebo. This controls participant expectations (a placebo effect from believing you have taken the drug) and experimenter bias in measuring.
Step 4: Weigh the evidence
Strengths: a controlled experiment with a control group, placebo and double-blind procedure, so the suppression can be attributed to the conditioned drink. It has been repeated by the same research group. Limitations: small samples of healthy volunteers, modest effects that fade when the CS is presented alone (extinction), and most of the evidence comes from a few laboratories.
Step 5: Conclude
The evidence supports the claim that immune responses can be classically conditioned in humans, but not yet that conditioning is large, lasting or reliable enough to replace part of a drug dose in patients.
Answer
(a) UCS: cyclosporin A; UCR: immune suppression to the drug; CS: the flavoured drink; CR: immune suppression to the drink alone. (b) The placebo lets the drink be tested without the drug while keeping the procedure the same; double-blind controls participant expectations and experimenter bias. (c) Good evidence that conditioning is possible, from a well-controlled design, but limited by small samples, short-lived effects and few independent replications.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.