Lesson 3: Little Albert, learned fear and the ethics of early conditioning
Evaluate the ethics of the Little Albert experiment
SkillsEthics of conditioning studiesLittle Albert and learned fear
Worked example
Watson and Rayner (1920) conditioned fear of a white rat in an 11-month-old infant by striking a steel bar behind his head as he reached for it. Identify three ethical principles the study breached, and explain how a researcher today would have to change the study (or why it could not be run).
Step 1: Protection from harm
Albert was deliberately and repeatedly frightened, and the fear generalised to a rabbit, a dog, a fur coat and a mask. Today an ethics committee would not approve a procedure intended to cause a lasting fear in any participant.
Step 2: Removing the harm
Albert left the hospital before any attempt to remove the fear, though the researchers knew he might. A researcher must reverse any harm a study causes, and follow up participants.
Step 3: Informed consent and voluntary participation
An infant cannot consent. His mother, who worked at the hospital, may not have felt free to refuse, and there is no record of what she was told. Today a parent would need full information, freely given consent, and no pressure from an employer.
Consent from someone in a dependent position (an employee of the institution) may not be voluntary.
Step 4: Withdrawal
Albert cried and crawled away, but the study continued. A child's distress counts as withdrawal; today the session would stop.
Step 5: Conclude
Because the aim itself was to cause fear, no change to the procedure would make it acceptable: the study could not be run today. A modern researcher would study fear conditioning with adult volunteers, a mild stimulus they can stop at any time, full consent and debriefing, and extinction before they leave.
Answer
Protection from harm (deliberate, generalising fear), no removal of harm (Albert left before deconditioning), and informed consent (an infant; a mother employed by the hospital); withdrawal rights also breached. It could not be run today; fear-conditioning research now uses consenting adults, mild stimuli, the right to stop, debriefing and extinction before they leave.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.