Lesson 9 of 10 · 18 min
Prevalence across cultures
Analyse prevalence data from different cultures, calculating from tables and explaining differences as real differences or as differences in reporting, stigma and diagnostic practice.
What you will be able to do
- Read prevalence tables and graphs, noting the period, population and source.
- Calculate numbers of people, differences in percentage points and ratios from prevalence data.
- Explain differences between cultures as real differences or as differences in reporting, stigma and diagnostic practice.
If one country reports twice the rate of anxiety disorders of another, do twice as many people there really have an anxiety disorder? Maybe. Or maybe more people there are willing to tell an interviewer about their worries, the survey's questions fit their way of describing distress better, or their doctors diagnose differently. Analysing prevalence data across cultures means doing the arithmetic carefully and asking what the numbers actually measure.
Definition
Prevalence
Prevalence is the proportion of a population with a disorder in a stated period, usually a percentage.
12-month prevalence counts people who met the criteria at some time in the past year; lifetime prevalence counts anyone who has ever met them.
Reading a prevalence table
Read the heading and notes
Which disorder, which period (12-month or lifetime), which population (ages, country), which source and years?
Read the units
Percentages of the population, numbers of people, or rates per 1000? Do not compare a percentage with a count.
Find the pattern
Which group is highest and lowest? By how much: in percentage points (a difference) or times (a ratio)?
Explain it
Give a possible real difference and a possible measurement difference, and say what data would tell them apart.
Real data. The WHO World Mental Health Surveys interviewed 147 261 adults face to face in 26 countries between 2001 and 2012, using the same structured interview translated into each language. For GAD they found a lifetime prevalence of 5.0% in high-income countries, 2.8% in middle-income countries and 1.6% in low-income countries (Ruscio et al., 2017).
Lifetime prevalence of GAD by country income group (Ruscio et al., 2017, WHO World Mental Health Surveys, 2001–2012).
Using the graph, how many times higher was the lifetime prevalence of GAD in high-income countries than in low-income countries? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Why might measured prevalence differ? Explanations fall into two groups.
Real differences in how many people have the disorder:
- Different levels of risk factors: poverty, conflict, disasters, unemployment, family breakdown.
- Different protective factors: close extended families and community ties can buffer stress.
- Different life pace and pressures, such as competitive schooling or long working hours.
Measurement differences, where the same true prevalence would be measured differently:
- Reporting and stigma. Where psychological disorder carries more shame, people are less willing to tell an interviewer about symptoms, so prevalence is under-counted.
- How distress is expressed. In some cultures distress is described mainly through the body (headaches, tiredness, pain) or in local terms, rather than as "worry" or "low mood". A questionnaire written around Western terms can miss it. The DSM-5-TR lists cultural concepts of distress such as taijin kyofusho in Japan (intense anxiety that one's body or behaviour offends others) and kufungisisa, "thinking too much", among Shona-speaking people of Zimbabwe.
- Diagnostic practice. The DSM and ICD were developed mostly in Western countries, and clinicians in different countries are trained differently, so the same symptoms may be diagnosed differently or not at all.
- Survey methods and access. Translation, who is sampled (cities only?), response rates and whether people have ever had a diagnosis all change the numbers.
Classify each explanation for a country's low measured prevalence of anxiety disorders as a real difference or a measurement difference.
The GAD data again. GAD was more common in richer countries even though, within each country, it is more common among poorer people (Ruscio et al., 2017). Something about life in high-income countries may raise the risk, which would be a real difference. But people in high-income countries may also be more familiar with the idea of anxiety as a health problem and more willing to report it, which would be a measurement difference. The data alone cannot decide between them; that needs research on how well the interview works in each culture, for example re-interviews by local clinicians.
Worked example
Explain a cross-cultural difference in GAD
The WHO World Mental Health Surveys found the lifetime prevalence of GAD was 5.0% in high-income countries and 1.6% in low-income countries (Ruscio et al., 2017).
Analyse this finding. Calculate how many times higher the high-income prevalence is, and give one possible real explanation and two possible measurement explanations for the difference. (5 marks)
Step 1: Calculate the ratio
, so GAD was about 3.1 times as common (3.4 percentage points higher) in high-income countries.
Step 2: A real explanation
Life in high-income countries may carry risk factors for chronic worry, such as more individual responsibility for success, long working hours and weaker extended-family support, which would mean more people truly have GAD.
Step 3: Measurement explanation 1
Reporting and stigma: people in some low-income countries may be less familiar with anxiety as a health problem, or more ashamed to report it, so fewer cases are counted.
Step 4: Measurement explanation 2
Expression and diagnostic practice: in some cultures anxiety is expressed through bodily complaints or local concepts such as "thinking too much", which an interview built on DSM criteria may not capture.
Step 5: Evaluate
The surveys used the same interview everywhere, which reduces some measurement differences, but the same words can mean different things in different cultures. Checking the interview against assessments by local clinicians would show how much of the gap is real.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
About 3.1 times higher. Real: different risk factors (pressures of life, weaker extended-family support). Measurement: stigma and unfamiliarity reduce reporting; anxiety expressed physically or in local terms is missed by DSM-based interviews. Local validation would show how much is real.
Method
Calculate the ratio or difference.
Give a real explanation and measurement explanations.
Say what evidence would tell them apart.
Watch out for
Giving only measurement explanations, or only real ones. The question asks for both.
Note
Compare like with like
Australia's 12-month prevalence of GAD was 3.8% (ABS, 2020–2022), about twice the 1.8% found across the WHO World Mental Health Surveys (2001–2012). Before reading that as "Australians worry more", check what differs: the surveys were done in different years, with different interviews, and the WHO figure averages 26 very different countries. Only figures from the same survey method, period and age range can be compared directly.
| Country | Anxiety disorders (%) | Depressive disorders (%) | Would be embarrassed (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 14.2 | 6.8 | 18 |
| B | 9.5 | 5.1 | 35 |
| C | 4.1 | 2.9 | 62 |
| D | 11.8 | 7.6 | 24 |
Worked example
Analyse a cross-cultural prevalence table
The fictional table below shows the 12-month prevalence of anxiety disorders in four countries, and the percentage of adults who say they would be embarrassed to see a mental health professional.
| Country | Anxiety disorders (%) | Would be embarrassed (%) |
|---|---|---|
| A | 14.2 | 18 |
| B | 9.5 | 35 |
| C | 4.1 | 62 |
| D | 11.8 | 24 |
(a) Calculate the difference between the highest and lowest prevalence in percentage points. (b) Describe the relationship between the two columns. (c) Explain why the measured prevalence in Country C may underestimate the true prevalence.
Step 1: (a) Highest minus lowest
Highest A , lowest C : percentage points.
Step 2: (b) Order the countries by embarrassment
From least to most embarrassed: A (18%), D (24%), B (35%), C (62%). Prevalence falls in the same order: 14.2, 11.8, 9.5, 4.1. The more embarrassed people are, the lower the measured prevalence: a negative relationship.
Step 3: (c) Link to stigma and reporting
In Country C, 62% would be embarrassed to see a professional, which suggests strong stigma. People who feel ashamed are less likely to tell an interviewer about anxiety symptoms, so some people with a disorder are not counted.
Step 4: Note the limit of the data
Four countries cannot show cause: Country C might also have truly lower anxiety. Interviews designed to reduce embarrassment, or checks by local clinicians, would help decide.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 10.1 percentage points. (b) A negative relationship: countries where more people would be embarrassed report lower prevalence. (c) Stigma in Country C may stop people reporting symptoms, so prevalence is under-counted, although a real difference cannot be ruled out from these data.
Method
Subtract percentages for a difference in percentage points.
Order the rows by one column and look at the other.
Link the pattern to reporting, and say what the data cannot show.
Watch out for
Writing "10.1% higher". It is 10.1 percentage points, or about 3.5 times as high.
Claiming embarrassment causes lower prevalence: the data are correlational.
Common mistake
Percentage points and per cent
Going from 4.1% to 14.2% is an increase of 10.1 percentage points, which is about 3.5 times as high. It is not "a 10.1% increase". Say which you mean.
Exam tip
Analyse means more than describe
To analyse prevalence data: state the trend with numbers, calculate a difference or ratio, then give at least one real and one measurement explanation, linked to evidence in the stimulus (such as an embarrassment column), and say what a correlation in the table does and does not show.
Summary
Check the period (12-month or lifetime), population, source and year before reading any prevalence figure.
Use percentage points for differences and "times" for ratios.
Real differences come from different risk and protective factors across cultures.
Measurement differences come from stigma and reporting, how distress is expressed, diagnostic practice and survey methods.
A pattern in the data rarely decides between them on its own: say what further evidence would.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.