Lesson 6 of 10 · 18 min

Comparing treatments for psychological disorders

Compare psychotherapies, pharmacotherapies, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and psychosurgery on how they work, what they treat, their evidence, side effects and reversibility.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe how psychotherapies, pharmacotherapies, ECT and psychosurgery work and what they are used for.
  • Compare the treatments on effectiveness, side effects, invasiveness and reversibility.
  • Explain why treatments are often combined, and why some are used only as a last resort.

The syllabus names four kinds of treatment. They range from talking with a trained therapist to surgery on the brain, and they are used in very different situations. A useful way to compare them is to ask the same questions of each: how does it work, what is it used for, how well does it work, what are its risks, and can it be undone?

Psychotherapies treat a disorder by psychological means, through a relationship with a trained therapist (a psychologist, a psychiatrist, a counsellor).

  • Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) helps a person notice unhelpful thoughts ("I'll definitely fail"), test them against the evidence and change unhelpful behaviours. It is a first-choice treatment for GAD and for depression.
  • Exposure therapy treats specific phobias. The person builds a hierarchy of feared situations, from a photo of a spider to holding a jar with a spider in it, and faces each step gradually, with relaxation and support, until the fear fades. Unlike avoidance, exposure lets the conditioned fear extinguish. It is the first-choice treatment for specific phobias.

Psychotherapies have few side effects and teach skills a person keeps after treatment ends, but they take weekly sessions over months, depend on a person's motivation, and can be costly or have waiting lists.

Pharmacotherapies treat a disorder with medication that changes neurotransmitter activity in the brain. A GP or psychiatrist prescribes them.

  • Antidepressants such as SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) increase serotonin's action at synapses. They are used for depression and for anxiety disorders, including GAD, and usually take a few weeks to work.
  • Benzodiazepines increase the inhibitory effect of GABA and reduce anxiety within an hour, but they can cause drowsiness and dependence, so they are used only for short periods.
  • Antipsychotics reduce dopamine activity and treat psychotic symptoms in schizophrenia; mood stabilisers such as lithium treat bipolar disorder.

Medications are quick to start and can reduce severe symptoms, but they have side effects (nausea, weight change, sleep problems), they treat symptoms rather than teach skills, and symptoms can return when they stop. They should be stopped only with a doctor's advice.

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) passes a brief, controlled electrical current through the scalp while the person is under a general anaesthetic and has been given a muscle relaxant, producing a seizure in the brain that lasts under a minute. A course is usually 6 to 12 sessions, a few days apart. ECT is used mainly for severe depression that has not responded to other treatments, or where a fast response is needed because the person's life is at risk.

ECT works well for severe depression and often faster than medication, but its common side effects are confusion straight after treatment and memory loss, usually for events around the time of treatment, which mostly recovers within weeks to months; some people report lasting gaps. In Queensland, ECT may be given only with the person's informed consent or the approval of the Mental Health Review Tribunal (Mental Health Act 2016).

Psychosurgery destroys or removes brain tissue to change thinking, mood or behaviour. In the 1930s to 1950s, prefrontal lobotomies cut connections to the frontal lobes in tens of thousands of people, many with no consent, leaving many apathetic, with changed personalities or disabled; some died. Egas Moniz, who introduced the operation, was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1949, which shows how differently treatments were judged then.

Modern procedures are far more precise and, in some countries, are used very rarely for severe obsessive-compulsive disorder or depression that has not responded to anything else. Psychosurgery is irreversible. It is prohibited in Queensland under the Mental Health Act 2016; non-destructive procedures such as deep brain stimulation are strictly regulated.

Interactive

Compare the four treatments

Open each treatment and compare how invasive and reversible it is. Then match the statements to the treatments.

The four treatments compared
CriterionPsychotherapyPharmacotherapyECTPsychosurgery
How it worksChanges thoughts, emotions and behaviour through learningChanges neurotransmitter activityA brief induced seizure changes brain activityDestroys or removes brain tissue
Typical useGAD, phobias, depression; often first choiceDepression, anxiety, schizophrenia, bipolar disorderSevere depression not helped by other treatmentsVery rarely, severe OCD or depression elsewhere; prohibited in Queensland
Main drawbacksTime, cost, effort; not quick in a crisisSide effects; symptoms may return on stoppingAnaesthetic; confusion and memory lossIrreversible; serious risks
InvasivenessNot invasiveLow: a tabletModerate: anaesthetic and seizureHigh: brain surgery
Reversible?YesYes, with medical adviceNo tissue is destroyedNo

Match each statement to the treatment it describes.

ECT

Produces a brief seizure; no tissue is destroyed. Used for severe depression. Side effects (confusion, memory loss) are mostly temporary. Regulated in Queensland: consent or Tribunal approval.

Psychosurgery

Destroys or removes brain tissue. Historically used widely and harmfully (lobotomy). Effects are permanent. Prohibited in Queensland.

Combining treatments. Treatments are often combined: medication can reduce severe symptoms enough for a person to engage in CBT, and CBT can lower the chance of relapse once medication stops. Health services use stepped care: start with the least intensive treatment likely to work (guided self-help, then psychotherapy, then medication or a combination), and move to more intensive treatment only if needed. ECT sits near the top of the steps, and psychosurgery, where it is allowed at all, at the very end.

Worked example

Compare CBT and an SSRI for GAD

  • Complex familiar

Compare cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) as treatments for a person with generalised anxiety disorder. Refer to how each works, its advantages and its limitations. (5 marks)

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Describe how each treatment works.

  2. Give at least one similarity and two differences, on the same criteria.

  3. Finish with a judgement or how they can be combined.

Watch out for

  • Describing each treatment in a separate paragraph without ever comparing them.

Why is exposure therapy, rather than medication, the first-choice treatment for a specific phobia?

Choose one answer

Exam tip

Comparing treatments

"Compare" means similarities and differences. Use the same criteria for each treatment, refer to a disorder, and end with a judgement if the question asks for one: "For a person with GAD, CBT and an SSRI are both first-choice treatments; CBT has fewer side effects and lower relapse after treatment, while an SSRI needs less time and effort each week."

Summary

  • Psychotherapies (CBT, exposure) change thoughts and behaviour; few side effects, lasting skills, but slow and effortful.

  • Pharmacotherapies change neurotransmitter activity (SSRIs, benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, lithium); quicker, but with side effects and relapse after stopping.

  • ECT induces a brief seizure under anaesthetic; effective for severe depression; memory loss is the main side effect.

  • Psychosurgery destroys brain tissue, is irreversible, has a harmful history and is prohibited in Queensland.

  • Treatments are often combined, from the least to the most intensive (stepped care).

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 6 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account