Lesson 7: The placebo effect
Identify the placebo effect in a trial
SkillsThe placebo effectAnalysing treatment trials
Worked example
In a fictional trial of a new tablet for specific phobia of spiders, fear ratings (0–100) fell by a mean of 30 points in the tablet group, 18 points in the placebo group and 5 points in the no-treatment group.
(a) Calculate the placebo effect and the treatment effect. (b) Explain what the placebo group's result shows.
Step 1: Placebo effect
Placebo no treatment points.
Step 2: Treatment effect
Tablet placebo points.
Subtracting the placebo group removes both natural change and the placebo effect, leaving what the active ingredient added.
Step 3: Explain the placebo result
The placebo group improved 13 points more than the no-treatment group although their tablet had no active ingredient. The extra improvement came from expecting to be treated: the placebo effect.
Answer
(a) Placebo effect 13 points; treatment effect 12 points. (b) Expectation alone reduced fear by 13 points more than no treatment, so a large part of the tablet group's 30-point improvement was not caused by the active ingredient.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Placebo effect = placebo − no treatment.
Treatment effect = treatment − placebo.
Interpret each difference in words, with units.
Watch out for
Giving 25 points (tablet − no treatment) as the treatment effect: it includes the placebo effect.