Lesson 7: The placebo effect

Evaluate and improve a treatment trial

SkillsDesigning treatment trialsThe placebo effect

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar

A fictional clinic wants to show that its new relaxation app reduces anxiety. Forty clients with GAD choose whether to use the app for six weeks; 20 do and 20 don't. The clinic's psychologist, who designed the app, rates every client's anxiety before and after. App users improve by a mean of 9 points and non-users by 3 points, and the clinic claims the app "reduces anxiety by 6 points".

Evaluate the clinic's claim and propose an improved design. (6 marks)

1 of 5 steps
  1. Step 1: Identify the allocation problem

    Clients chose their own group. People who choose an app may be more motivated or less severely anxious, a participant variable that could cause the difference instead of the app. Random allocation would spread these differences evenly.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Look for problems with allocation, expectations and who measures the outcome.

  2. Say how each could produce the result without the treatment working.

  3. Make a judgement about the claim.

  4. Propose a design that fixes each problem.

Watch out for

  • Suggesting "a larger sample" as the only improvement: it improves reliability but not the confounds.

Save your progress with a free account