Lesson 6: Comparing treatments for psychological disorders
Compare CBT and an SSRI for GAD
SkillComparing treatments
Worked example
Compare cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) as treatments for a person with generalised anxiety disorder. Refer to how each works, its advantages and its limitations. (5 marks)
Step 1: How each works
CBT is a psychotherapy: the person learns to identify and challenge worrying thoughts and change avoidant behaviour. An SSRI is a pharmacotherapy that increases serotonin's action at synapses.
Step 2: A similarity
Both are first-choice, evidence-based treatments for GAD, both are non-invasive, and both take several weeks to help.
Step 3: Differences in advantages
CBT has few side effects and teaches skills the person keeps, so relapse after treatment is lower. An SSRI needs less time and effort each week and can reduce severe symptoms enough for a person to engage in therapy.
Step 4: Differences in limitations
CBT needs motivation and regular sessions and can be costly or have waiting lists. An SSRI can cause side effects (nausea, sleep problems), and symptoms can return when it is stopped, which should only happen with a doctor's advice.
Step 5: Judgement
They are often combined: medication eases symptoms while CBT builds skills that last.
Answer
Both CBT and SSRIs are non-invasive, first-choice treatments for GAD that take weeks to work. CBT changes thoughts and behaviour, has few side effects and lower relapse but needs time, effort and access; an SSRI changes serotonin activity, needs less effort but has side effects and symptoms may return when it stops. They are often combined.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe how each treatment works.
Give at least one similarity and two differences, on the same criteria.
Finish with a judgement or how they can be combined.
Watch out for
Describing each treatment in a separate paragraph without ever comparing them.