Lesson 1: The two-factor and appraisal theories of emotion
Evaluate the Schachter & Singer (1962) experiment
SkillTwo-factor and appraisal theories
Worked example
Identify the independent variables in Schachter & Singer's (1962) experiment, and evaluate it as evidence for the two-factor theory, with reference to one strength, one methodological limitation and one ethical issue. (5 marks)
Step 1: Identify the independent variables
Two IVs were manipulated: arousal and its explanation (adrenaline with the true effects explained, with no explanation, with false effects, or a saline placebo), and the situational cue (a euphoric or an angry confederate).
Step 2: A strength
It was a controlled experiment that manipulated arousal and the available explanation directly, so it could test the theory's causal claim: unexplained arousal is labelled from situational cues.
Step 3: A methodological limitation
The effects were small and several differences were not significant; later replications (Marshall & Zimbardo 1979; Maslach 1979) did not find that unexplained arousal took on the confederate's mood. The sample was male university students only, limiting generalisation.
Step 4: An ethical issue
Participants were deceived about the injection and the aim, so they could not give informed consent to receiving adrenaline, and the anger condition's insulting questionnaire risked distress.
Step 5: Judge
The design was a clever test of the theory, but weak, poorly replicated results and serious ethical problems mean it gives limited support.
Answer
IVs: arousal and its explanation (informed, ignorant, misinformed, placebo) and the confederate's mood (euphoric or angry). Strength: a controlled manipulation of the very things the theory says cause emotion. Limitation: small, partly non-significant effects that later replications did not reproduce, and an all-male student sample. Ethics: deception about the drug and aim prevented informed consent, and the insulting questionnaire risked distress. Overall, limited support.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name the variables the researchers manipulated and measured.
Give a strength tied to the theory's claim.
Give a limitation of the method or results, and an ethical issue.
Finish with a judgement.