Lesson 1: The two-factor and appraisal theories of emotion
Compare the two-factor and appraisal theories for a near miss
SkillTwo-factor and appraisal theories
Worked example
Sam is riding his bike when a car pulls out in front of him and he brakes hard, just missing it. A second later he is shaking, his heart is pounding, and he sees the driver laughing. Sam feels furious.
Compare how the two-factor theory (Schachter & Singer 1962) and the appraisal theory (Lazarus 1982) explain Sam's anger. (5 marks)
Step 1: Apply the two-factor theory to Sam
The near miss produces physiological arousal first: shaking and a pounding heart. Sam looks to the situation to explain it; the laughing driver is the cue, so he labels his arousal as anger.
Use the theory's terms (arousal, cognitive label, situational cue) and point to the detail in the scenario that fits each.
Step 2: Apply the appraisal theory to Sam
Sam's primary appraisal judges the event as harm to his wellbeing (he was nearly hit, and the driver is mocking him); his secondary appraisal judges he can do something (confront the driver). This pattern of appraisal (another person to blame for a harm) produces anger, and the anger comes with arousal.
Step 3: State a similarity
Both theories say cognition decides which emotion Sam feels: without thinking about the situation, his arousal would not be anger in particular.
Step 4: State the differences
In the two-factor theory the arousal comes first and the cognition labels it; in the appraisal theory the appraisal comes first and the arousal follows from it. The two-factor cognition is an explanation of his arousal from cues; the appraisal is an evaluation of what the event means for him and how he can cope.
Each difference is stated for both theories in one sentence, with a comparative word ("whereas", "while").
Step 5: Add an evaluative point
Sam's fright began within a fraction of a second, before he could have appraised anything, which fits the arousal-first order better; but the anger only appeared once he saw the driver laughing, a cue both theories can use.
Answer
Both theories say cognition decides the emotion. In the two-factor theory, Sam's arousal (shaking, pounding heart) comes first and he labels it anger from the cue of the laughing driver, whereas in the appraisal theory he first appraises the event as harm caused by someone to blame (primary) that he can confront (secondary), and the anger and its arousal follow. The two-factor cognition explains arousal already present; the appraisal evaluates the event's meaning for his wellbeing.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Apply each theory to the scenario, naming its terms.
State one similarity.
State the differences: the order of arousal and cognition, and what the cognition is about.
Use comparative words and the scenario's details throughout.
Watch out for
Describing each theory in general terms without Sam's details.
Writing two separate paragraphs with no "whereas" or "both".