Lesson 8: Diagnosis in context
Consequences of receiving a diagnosis
SkillConsequences of a diagnosis
Worked example
A fictional student, Maya, aged 16, has been diagnosed with a depressive disorder by a psychiatrist after several months of low mood.
Explain one beneficial, one harmful and one unintended consequence that the diagnosis could have for Maya.
Step 1: A beneficial consequence
The diagnosis gives access to treatment and support: sessions with a psychologist with a Medicare rebate, and adjustments at school such as extensions. It may also bring relief: Maya learns her experience has a name and is not a personal failing.
Step 2: A harmful consequence
Stigma: if classmates find out, some may treat Maya differently or exclude her, which could deepen her low mood.
Step 3: An unintended consequence
A self-fulfilling prophecy: if Maya, her teachers or her parents come to expect less of her because of the label, she may attempt less, achieve less and feel worse, which seems to confirm the label.
An unintended consequence is a side effect nobody aimed for, arising from how people react to the label.
Answer
Beneficial: access to treatment, support and school adjustments, and relief at an explanation. Harmful: stigma from peers. Unintended: lowered expectations that become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Beneficial: what the diagnosis opens up (treatment, support, understanding).
Harmful: how others or the person themselves may respond to the label.
Unintended: a side effect nobody intended, such as changed expectations.
Watch out for
Listing consequences without explaining how each would affect Maya.