Lesson 9: Information processing and comparing the theories
Analyse recall data for two age groups
SkillsInformation processingResearch methods and ethics
Worked example
Illustrative data: six 5-year-olds and six 10-year-olds were shown 12 pictures and asked to recall them after a short delay. Observers noted that none of the 5-year-olds rehearsed aloud and five of the 10-year-olds did.
| Pictures recalled | |
|---|---|
| 5-year-olds | 4, 5, 3, 6, 4, 5 |
| 10-year-olds | 8, 9, 7, 10, 8, 9 |
(a) Calculate the mean and the sample standard deviation for each group, to 2 decimal places. (b) Identify the research design. (c) Explain the difference in recall using information processing theory.
Step 1: (a) Means
5-year-olds: . 10-year-olds: .
Step 2: (a) Standard deviations
For the 5-year-olds the deviations are ; their squares sum to . . The 10-year-olds' scores are each exactly 4 more, so their deviations, and , are the same: .
Adding the same amount to every score shifts the mean but not the spread.
Step 3: (b) Design
Age is a characteristic the researcher can't allocate, and the two age groups are different children: a quasi-experiment comparing groups (cross-sectional).
Step 4: (c) Explain
The 10-year-olds recalled 4 more pictures on average, with the same spread. Most of them rehearsed, a cognitive strategy that keeps information active in memory, while the 5-year-olds didn't use it spontaneously. Faster processing speed and better metacognition (knowing they needed to try to remember) may also contribute.
Answer
(a) 5-year-olds: mean 4.50, SD 1.05. 10-year-olds: mean 8.50, SD 1.05. (b) A quasi-experiment comparing two age groups. (c) Older children spontaneously used rehearsal (a cognitive strategy), helped by faster processing and better metacognition, so they recalled more.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Mean: sum ÷ n. Sample SD: square the deviations, divide by n − 1, take the square root.
Name the design: a pre-existing difference such as age makes it quasi-experimental.
Explain with a named information processing factor.
Watch out for
Dividing by instead of for the sample SD (which gives 0.96).
Calling it a true experiment: age can't be randomly allocated.