Lesson 10: Technology and the developing mind
Interpret a correlation between screen time and planning
SkillsReading correlational evidenceResearch methods and ethics
Worked example
Illustrative data: 15 Year 11 students recorded their average daily recreational screen time and completed a planning task scored out of 20. Pearson's correlation coefficient is .
(a) Describe the relationship. (b) Use to find , and state whether the correlation is significant, given that . (c) A student concludes, "Screen time makes teenagers worse at planning." Evaluate this conclusion.
Step 1: (a) Direction and strength
is negative and its size is between 0.5 and 0.75: a moderate negative correlation. Students with more screen time tended to score lower on planning.
Step 2: (b) Calculate t
, with .
Step 3: (b) Decide on significance
, so the correlation is statistically significant: we reject the null hypothesis that there is no correlation in the population.
Step 4: (c) Name the problem
The study is correlational: neither variable was manipulated, so it can't show cause.
Step 5: (c) Give alternatives
The direction could be reversed: students who find planning hard may drift to screens. A third variable, such as less sleep, could reduce planning and go with more screen time.
Step 6: (c) Note the other limitations
Fifteen students from one class is a small, convenience sample, and screen time was self-reported, which may be inaccurate. A justified conclusion: "In this sample, more screen time was associated with lower planning scores."
Answer
(a) A moderate negative correlation. (b) (); , so it is significant. (c) The conclusion claims cause from a correlation; the direction could be reversed or a third variable such as sleep could explain it, and the sample is small and self-reported. Only an association can be concluded.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe direction and strength from .
Calculate (df = n − 2) and compare with 0.05.
Evaluate: causation, direction, third variables, sample and measurement.
Watch out for
Forgetting that a significant correlation is still only an association.
Using instead of in the formula for .