Lesson 10: Technology and the developing mind
Draw a conclusion from a secondary source
SkillsReading correlational evidenceResearch methods and ethics
Worked example
A news website reports: "Phones are wrecking teens' focus. A new survey of 1,200 Australian 14- to 16-year-olds found that those who check their phones most often during homework scored lowest on a test of ignoring distractions (, )."
Using this secondary source, draw a conclusion about the relationship between phone use and adolescents' ability to focus on relevant information. Justify your conclusion and suggest how the evidence could be strengthened.
Step 1: Identify the variables and design
Co-variables: how often students check their phones during homework, and a score on a test of ignoring distractions (focusing on relevant information). Both were measured, not manipulated: a correlational survey.
Step 2: Describe the relationship
: a weak negative correlation (its size is between 0.25 and 0.5). With 1,200 participants, , so it is significant: unlikely to be chance, but small. Phone checking accounts for only a small part of the differences in focus between students.
Step 3: Consider other explanations
Reverse direction: students who already find it hard to ignore distractions may check their phones more. Third variables: tiredness, stress or ADHD symptoms could affect both. Phone checking was probably self-reported.
Step 4: State the conclusion
"Among these Australian 14- to 16-year-olds, checking a phone more often during homework was weakly associated with a poorer ability to ignore distractions." The headline's "wrecking" claims a cause and a large effect that the evidence doesn't support.
Step 5: Suggest how to strengthen it
Record phone use objectively with an app; measure the same students over time (does heavy checking come before a decline?); control for sleep and stress; or run an experiment in which students are randomly allocated to do homework with their phone in another room or on the desk.
Answer
There is a weak but significant negative association between phone checking during homework and the ability to ignore distractions in this large sample. Because the study is correlational, the direction could be reversed or a third variable could explain it, so the evidence does not show that phones cause poorer focus. Objective measures, following students over time, controlling third variables or an experiment with random allocation would strengthen it.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify the variables, how they were measured, and the design.
Interpret (direction and strength) and together with .
Consider reverse direction and third variables.
Write the conclusion as an association; suggest better evidence.
Watch out for
Treating "significant" as "large". With 1,200 participants a weak correlation can be significant.
Repeating the headline's causal language.