Lesson 3: Simultaneity is relative
Which lightning strike came first?
SkillRelativity of simultaneity
Worked example
A train travels east at high speed past a platform. Lightning strikes the west end (A) and the east end (B) of the train, leaving marks on the train and the platform. An observer on the platform, halfway between the marks on the platform, receives both flashes at the same instant.
Explain which strike happened first according to a passenger seated at the exact centre of the train.
Step 1: Platform frame
The platform observer is equidistant from both marks, and both flashes travel at . They arrive together, so the strikes were simultaneous in the platform frame.
Step 2: Track the passenger in the platform frame
While the light travels, the passenger moves east, towards B's flash and away from A's. So B's flash reaches the passenger first. Every observer agrees on this, because the arrival of a flash at the passenger is a single event at one place.
Step 3: Reason in the passenger's frame
In the train frame, the passenger is at rest, halfway between the marks on the train, and each flash travels towards them at (second postulate). Equal distances at equal speeds take equal times.
The passenger cannot say "I moved towards B", because in their own frame they are at rest.
Step 4: Conclude
Since B's flash arrived first but took the same time to travel, strike B must have happened first in the train frame.
Answer
In the passenger's frame strike B, at the east end (towards the direction of the train's motion), happened before strike A. Events that are simultaneous in the platform frame are not simultaneous in the train frame.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Decide what each observer receives, and when.
In each observer's own frame, light travels at in every direction.
Equal distances at equal speeds: the flash that arrives first was emitted first.
Watch out for
Saying the strikes "only look" non-simultaneous because of the light delay. The passenger has corrected for the delay; the order really is different in their frame.