Lesson 7: The evidence for time dilation and length contraction
Atmospheric muons in two frames
SkillsEvidence for relativityTime dilation calculationsLength contraction calculations
Worked example
A muon is created above the ground and travels straight down at . Muons at rest have a mean lifetime of .
Show that the Earth frame and the muon frame agree on how many mean lifetimes pass during the trip, and compare with the classical prediction.
Step 1: Find the Lorentz factor
, and
Step 2: Earth frame: the trip time
The height is a proper length for Earth.
Step 3: Earth frame: the dilated lifetime
The muon's clock runs slow: . Number of lifetimes:
Step 4: Muon frame: the contracted atmosphere
The muon's is a proper time. The atmosphere moves, so . Time for the ground to arrive: , which is lifetimes.
Step 5: Compare with classical physics
Classically, lifetimes pass. The surviving fraction after mean lifetimes is : about with relativity, but only classically.
Detectors at sea level find large numbers of muons, matching the relativistic prediction.
Answer
Both frames give mean lifetimes for the trip, so about of muons reach the ground. Classical physics predicts lifetimes and almost no survivors, contradicting observation.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Earth frame: proper length, dilated lifetime .
Muon frame: proper lifetime, contracted distance .
Both frames must agree on what happens to the muon.
Watch out for
Using time dilation and length contraction together in the same frame (double counting).
Treating the muon's lifetime as dilated.