Lesson 10: Paradoxes: twins, flashlights and a ladder in a barn
Will the ladder fit in the barn?
SkillsRelativity paradoxesLength contraction calculationsRelativity of simultaneity
Worked example
A ladder has a proper length of . A barn with doors at both ends has a proper length of .
(a) Calculate the speed at which the ladder just fits inside the barn, in the barn's frame.
(b) At that speed, calculate the length of the barn in the ladder's frame.
(c) Explain how both frames can be correct.
Step 1: Barn frame condition
Step 2: Solve for the speed
Step 3: Barn in the ladder frame
The barn moves at relative to the ladder: , far shorter than the ladder.
Step 4: Resolve with simultaneity
In the barn frame both doors can be closed at the same instant with the ladder inside. The two door closings happen at different places, so they are not simultaneous in the ladder frame: there, the far door closes first (before the back of the ladder enters) and the near door closes later (after the front has passed the far door). Only in the barn frame are both doors ever closed around the ladder at the same instant.
Disagreement about simultaneity of separated events is exactly what special relativity predicts.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) The doors closing "at the same time" is simultaneous only in the barn frame; in the ladder frame the far door closes first, so there is no contradiction.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Set the contracted length equal to the space available and solve for .
Each frame sees the other object contracted.
Resolve with the relativity of simultaneity.
Watch out for
Saying the ladder is "really" . Length depends on the frame.