Lesson 6: From Rutherford's atom to Bohr's atom
Comparing the Rutherford and Bohr models
SkillRutherford and Bohr atoms
Worked example
Compare the models of the atom proposed by Rutherford and Bohr. (4 marks)
Step 1: Decide what 'compare' needs
'Compare' means give similarities and differences. Four marks suggests two of each, or one similarity and three differences, each clearly linked to both models.
Step 2: Similarity 1, the nucleus
Both models have a tiny, dense, positively charged nucleus containing nearly all the atom's mass, with the electrons outside it in mostly empty space.
Step 3: Similarity 2, orbiting electrons
In both, electrons orbit the nucleus, held in circular paths by electrostatic attraction.
Step 4: Difference 1, allowed orbits and energies
In Rutherford's model an electron could orbit at any radius with any energy. In Bohr's model only certain orbits are allowed, so the electron's energy is quantised into fixed levels.
Step 5: Difference 2, radiation, stability and spectra
Rutherford's orbiting electrons should radiate continuously and spiral into the nucleus, giving unstable atoms and a continuous spectrum. Bohr's electrons do not radiate in an allowed orbit. They emit or absorb a single photon, with , only when they jump between orbits, which explains stable atoms and hydrogen's line spectrum.
The second difference is the one that shows why Bohr's model has greater explanatory power.
Answer
Both models have a tiny, dense, positive nucleus holding nearly all the atom's mass, and both have electrons orbiting it under electrostatic attraction in mostly empty space. In Rutherford's model, electrons can orbit at any radius with any energy, so they should radiate as they accelerate, spiral into the nucleus and give a continuous spectrum. In Bohr's model, electrons can occupy only certain allowed orbits with fixed, quantised energies, and do not radiate while in them. They emit or absorb one photon () only when jumping between orbits, which explains why atoms are stable and why hydrogen has a line spectrum.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Give at least one similarity and one difference, using both models in each sentence.
Cover the key difference: quantised orbits and energy levels.
Link the difference to the evidence it explains (stability, line spectra).
Watch out for
Describing each model separately without actually comparing them.
Giving only differences, which 'compare' does not allow.