Lesson 2 of 8 · 16 min

The ambiguous case

Recognise when two sides and a non-included angle fit no triangle, one triangle or two, and find every triangle that fits.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why SSA information (two sides and an angle not between them) can fit two different triangles.
  • Decide how many triangles fit by comparing the side opposite the angle with the height bsin⁡(A)b\sin(A) and the other side.
  • Find both possible angles, θ\theta and 180∘−θ180^\circ - \theta, and test each against the angle sum.
  • Complete both triangles when two exist.

Give three people the same instructions: "Draw angle A=40∘A = 40^\circ. Make AC=8AC = 8 cm. Then draw CB=6CB = 6 cm to meet the other arm of the angle." Collect the triangles and you will see two different shapes. Both follow the instructions exactly.

This is the ambiguous case of the sine rule. Two sides and an angle that is not between them (SSA) do not always pin down one triangle.

Side CB=6CB = 6 swings like a gate hinged at CC. It meets the base line at B1B_1 and at B2B_2, so two triangles fit.

Triangle CB1B2CB_1B_2 is isosceles, because CB1=CB2=6CB_1 = CB_2 = 6. So its base angles are equal, and the angle AB2CAB_2C is the supplement of the angle AB1CAB_1C. The two possible values of BB add to 180∘180^\circ.

The sine rule sees this coming: sin⁡(B)=8sin⁡(40∘)6≈0.857\sin(B) = \frac{8\sin(40^\circ)}{6} \approx 0.857 is satisfied by B≈59.0∘B \approx 59.0^\circ and B≈121.0∘B \approx 121.0^\circ, because sin⁡(180∘−θ)=sin⁡(θ)\sin(180^\circ - \theta) = \sin(\theta).

Interactive

Swing the gate

Shrink aa below about 5.1 and the gate cannot reach the base line: no triangle. Make aa larger than 8 and only one of the two crossings is on the right side of AA: one triangle.

Key idea

How many triangles? (A acute)

Given AA, bb and the side aa opposite AA, the height from CC to the base line is h=bsin⁡(A)h = b\sin(A).

  • a<ha < h: the gate is too short. No triangle.
  • a=ha = h: it just touches. One right-angled triangle.
  • h<a<bh < a < b: it crosses twice on the same side of AA. Two triangles.
  • a≥ba \ge b: the second crossing is behind AA. One triangle.

If AA is obtuse, there is one triangle when a>ba > b and none otherwise.

Angle A=30∘A = 30^\circ, b=10b = 10 cm and a=7a = 7 cm. How many triangles ABCABC fit this information?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Two triangles from the same information

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

In triangle ABCABC, A=32∘A = 32^\circ, a=7a = 7 cm and b=11b = 11 cm.

Find all possible values of BB and of cc, correct to one decimal place.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Find sin⁡(B)\sin(B) with the sine rule; list θ\theta and 180∘−θ180^\circ - \theta.

  2. Keep the obtuse value only if the angles still add to less than 180°.

  3. Complete each triangle separately with the angle sum and the sine rule.

Watch out for

  • Giving only 56.4∘56.4^\circ, the calculator's answer.

  • Mixing the triangles: pairing B=123.6∘B = 123.6^\circ with c=13.2c = 13.2 cm.

  • Rounding BB to 56.4∘56.4^\circ before finding CC and cc; keep the stored value.

Common mistake

Throwing away the obtuse answer

Your calculator gives only sin⁡−1(0.8327)≈56.4∘\sin^{-1}(0.8327) \approx 56.4^\circ. Always write down 180∘−56.4∘=123.6∘180^\circ - 56.4^\circ = 123.6^\circ as a candidate, then test it: does it leave room for the given angle? If the given angle plus the candidate is less than 180∘180^\circ, the candidate is a real second triangle.

In triangle ABCABC, A=41∘A = 41^\circ, a=9a = 9 cm and b=12b = 12 cm. Find all possible values of BB, correct to one decimal place. Enter the angles in degrees, separated by commas.

B =

Press Enter or type a comma after each value.

Worked example

How many triangles?

  • Simple familiar
  • Technology active

Angle A=50∘A = 50^\circ and b=10b = 10 cm. For each length of the side aa opposite AA, decide how many triangles ABCABC are possible.

(i) a=7a = 7 cm (ii) a=8a = 8 cm (iii) a=12a = 12 cm

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Compute h=bsin⁡(A)h = b\sin(A).

  2. Compare: a<ha < h none, a=ha = h one, h<a<bh < a < b two, a≥ba \ge b one.

Watch out for

  • Comparing aa with bb only, without the height hh.

Exam tip

Justify the number of triangles

Markers look for the test, not just the answer. Write a line like "41∘+119.0∘<180∘41^\circ + 119.0^\circ < 180^\circ, so this triangle exists" or "70∘+125∘>180∘70^\circ + 125^\circ > 180^\circ, so it is rejected". A question that says "find all possible values" is often hinting at two.

Summary

  • SSA data (two sides and a non-included angle) can fit no triangle, one, or two.

  • The sine rule gives sin⁡(B)=k\sin(B) = k. Both θ=sin⁡−1(k)\theta = \sin^{-1}(k) and 180∘−θ180^\circ - \theta are candidates.

  • Keep the obtuse candidate only if it plus the given angle is less than 180∘180^\circ.

  • For acute AA: a<bsin⁡(A)a < b\sin(A) none; a=bsin⁡(A)a = b\sin(A) one; bsin⁡(A)<a<bb\sin(A) < a < b two; a≥ba \ge b one.

  • When there are two triangles, complete both: each has its own third angle and third side.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 2 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account