Lesson 2 of 8 · 16 min
The ambiguous case
Recognise when two sides and a non-included angle fit no triangle, one triangle or two, and find every triangle that fits.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why SSA information (two sides and an angle not between them) can fit two different triangles.
- Decide how many triangles fit by comparing the side opposite the angle with the height and the other side.
- Find both possible angles, and , and test each against the angle sum.
- Complete both triangles when two exist.
Give three people the same instructions: "Draw angle . Make cm. Then draw cm to meet the other arm of the angle." Collect the triangles and you will see two different shapes. Both follow the instructions exactly.
This is the ambiguous case of the sine rule. Two sides and an angle that is not between them (SSA) do not always pin down one triangle.
Side swings like a gate hinged at . It meets the base line at and at , so two triangles fit.
Triangle is isosceles, because . So its base angles are equal, and the angle is the supplement of the angle . The two possible values of add to .
The sine rule sees this coming: is satisfied by and , because .
Shrink below about 5.1 and the gate cannot reach the base line: no triangle. Make larger than 8 and only one of the two crossings is on the right side of : one triangle.
Key idea
How many triangles? (A acute)
Given , and the side opposite , the height from to the base line is .
- : the gate is too short. No triangle.
- : it just touches. One right-angled triangle.
- : it crosses twice on the same side of . Two triangles.
- : the second crossing is behind . One triangle.
If is obtuse, there is one triangle when and none otherwise.
Angle , cm and cm. How many triangles fit this information?
Worked example
Two triangles from the same information
In triangle , , cm and cm.
Find all possible values of and of , correct to one decimal place.
Step 1: Use the sine rule for
Step 2: List both candidates
and .
, so two angles between and have this sine.
Step 3: Test the obtuse candidate
, so there is room for . Both triangles exist.
Equivalently: , and , so the side meets the base line twice.
Step 4: Find in each triangle
and .
Step 5: Find in each triangle
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
with cm, or with cm.
Method
Find with the sine rule; list and .
Keep the obtuse value only if the angles still add to less than 180°.
Complete each triangle separately with the angle sum and the sine rule.
Watch out for
Giving only , the calculator's answer.
Mixing the triangles: pairing with cm.
Rounding to before finding and ; keep the stored value.
Common mistake
Throwing away the obtuse answer
Your calculator gives only . Always write down as a candidate, then test it: does it leave room for the given angle? If the given angle plus the candidate is less than , the candidate is a real second triangle.
In triangle , , cm and cm. Find all possible values of , correct to one decimal place. Enter the angles in degrees, separated by commas.
Worked example
How many triangles?
Angle and cm. For each length of the side opposite , decide how many triangles are possible.
(i) cm (ii) cm (iii) cm
Step 1: Find the height from
cm.
Side swings from . It must be at least as long as the shortest distance from to the base line, which is the perpendicular height.
Step 2: (i)
: the side is too short to reach the base line. No triangle.
Step 3: (ii)
: the side reaches the base line at two points on the same side of . Two triangles.
Step 4: (iii)
: one crossing is on the far side of , which would not make angle . One triangle.
Step 5: Confirm (ii) with the sine rule
, so or , and . Two triangles.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(i) none, (ii) two, (iii) one.
Method
Compute .
Compare: none, one, two, one.
Watch out for
Comparing with only, without the height .
Exam tip
Justify the number of triangles
Markers look for the test, not just the answer. Write a line like ", so this triangle exists" or ", so it is rejected". A question that says "find all possible values" is often hinting at two.
Summary
SSA data (two sides and a non-included angle) can fit no triangle, one, or two.
The sine rule gives . Both and are candidates.
Keep the obtuse candidate only if it plus the given angle is less than .
For acute : none; one; two; one.
When there are two triangles, complete both: each has its own third angle and third side.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.