Lesson 7: Solving problems with the rules
The cheapest route for a power cable
SkillsGradients, tangents and stationary pointsThe chain rule
Worked example
An island is 3 km offshore from the nearest point on a straight coastline. A town is on the coast 8 km from . A power cable will run underwater from to a point on the coast, km from , and then along the coast to . Underwater cable costs $500 000 per km and cable on land costs $400 000 per km.
(a) Show that the cost, in thousands of dollars, is for .
(b) Find the value of that minimises the cost, and the minimum cost.
(c) Evaluate the reasonableness of your answer.
Step 1: (a) Length of each section
By Pythagoras, km. Along the coast, km.
Step 2: (a) Cost
In thousands of dollars, , as required.
Step 3: (b) Differentiate
Step 4: (b) Solve C′(x) = 0
, so .
Square both sides: , so and (as ).
Squaring can introduce false solutions, so check: and .
Step 5: (b) Compare with the endpoints
,
Step 6: (c) Reasonableness
The minimum, $4.1 million at , is less than both endpoint costs, so it is the global minimum on . It makes sense that the cable comes ashore part of the way along: underwater cable is dearer, so it pays to shorten the underwater section, but not all the way to , because then the land section is long.
Answer
(b) Bring the cable ashore 4 km from . The minimum cost is $4 100 000. (c) This is cheaper than both extremes ($4.7 million at and about $4.27 million at ), so it is the minimum on the domain.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Build the model from the diagram with Pythagoras.
Differentiate with the chain rule and solve the derivative equal to zero.
Compare the stationary value with the endpoints of the domain, and interpret in context.
Watch out for
Forgetting the derivative of is , not 0.
Not checking the endpoints, so not knowing whether the stationary point is the global minimum.
Mixing units: the model is in thousands of dollars.