Lesson 4 of 7 · 16 min
Opening balances, time to a goal and comparing plans
Add an opening balance to regular deposits, find how many periods a savings goal takes with a table or technology, and compare savings plans.
What you will be able to do
- Find the balance of an account with an opening balance and regular deposits, using the recurrence relation or .
- Find the number of periods needed to reach a goal using a table of values or trial and improvement.
- Compare savings plans with different deposits, frequencies or rates, and justify a choice.
Real savings rarely start from $0. You might already have $5000 in the bank before you start a regular plan. Two things then grow at once: the money already there earns compound interest, and the new deposits build up as an annuity.
The recurrence relation handles this with no extra work — just start at instead of . With the formulas, you add the two parts.
Worked example
An opening balance plus quarterly deposits
Hugo has $5000 in an investment account that pays 6% p.a. compounded quarterly. He adds $250 at the end of every quarter. Find the value of the account after 8 years, and the interest earned.
Step 1: Find i and n
and .
Step 2: Grow the opening balance
The $5000 is a lump sum, so it grows as compound interest, .
Step 3: Find the future value of the deposits
Step 4: Add the two parts
This is exactly what you get by running , , 32 times.
Step 5: Find the interest
Paid in: . Interest: .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
After 8 years the account holds $18 223.69, of which $5223.69 is interest.
Method
Grow the opening balance: .
Add the future value of the deposits, .
Interest = total − (opening balance + ).
Watch out for
Adding $5000 without growing it, which gives $15 172.07.
Leaving the opening balance out of "paid in" when finding the interest.
Sophie has $1000 in an account paying 3.6% p.a. compounded monthly. She adds $100 at the end of every month. Find her balance after 2 years, correct to the nearest cent.
How long will it take? Sometimes the deposit is fixed and the question is when the goal is reached. The syllabus solves this with technology or a table, not logarithms: work out the balance for a few values of and find the first one that reaches the goal.
Worked example
How long until the goal?
Ruby can afford to save $500 at the end of every month. Her account pays 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly. How many months will it take her to save at least $25 000?
Step 1: Set up the future value
, so after months .
Step 2: Make a first estimate
Without interest it would take months. With interest it will be a little sooner, so try values in the mid-40s.
Step 3: Try values of n
44 $24 002.44 45 $24 598.45 46 $25 196.84 Use technology (a table of values, a spreadsheet, or the calculator's table mode) or trial and improvement with the formula. QCAA does not expect logarithms here.
Step 4: Choose the first n that reaches the goal
After 45 months Ruby is $401.55 short. After 46 months she has $25 196.84, so she first reaches the goal after 46 months.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Ruby reaches $25 000 after 46 months (3 years and 10 months).
Method
Write in terms of .
Estimate n from goal ÷ deposit, then try nearby values.
Give the first whole number of periods that reaches the goal.
Watch out for
Rounding to the nearer month: after 45 months the goal has not been reached, even though it is close.
Answering 50 months by ignoring the interest.
Lachlan saves $300 at the end of every month in an account paying 6% p.a. compounded monthly. The table shows his balance after months. After how many months does his balance first reach $10 000?
Comparing plans. Two plans can deposit the same total and still end with different balances. What matters is how early the money goes in, the rate, and how often interest is compounded. Compare monthly deposits of $400 with quarterly deposits of $1200, both at 4.8% p.a. for 10 years.
Both plans pay in $48 000. The monthly plan finishes about $306 ahead: its money goes in sooner and compounds more often. Raise the rate and watch the gap grow.
Worked example
Monthly or quarterly saving?
Grace can save $4800 a year for 10 years. She is choosing between two accounts:
- Account A: $400 at the end of every month, 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly.
- Account B: $1200 at the end of every quarter, 4.8% p.a. compounded quarterly.
Evaluate the two plans and recommend one, with reasons.
Step 1: Account A
, :
Step 2: Account B
, :
Step 3: Compare like with like
Both plans deposit . Interest: A earns ; B earns . A is ahead by .
Same total deposited, same nominal rate and same term, so the difference is entirely due to timing and compounding.
Step 4: Explain why
In Account A, money goes in sooner: $400 is already earning interest at the end of month 1, while Account B waits until the end of month 3. A's interest is also compounded monthly, a slightly higher effective rate.
Step 5: Recommend, with a limitation
Account A gives $306.42 more over 10 years, so it is the better choice, provided Grace's income lets her deposit monthly. The difference is small (about 0.5% of the final balance), so fees, flexibility or a change in rates could easily matter more.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Account A grows to $61 452.78 and Account B to $61 146.36. Recommend A: it earns $306.42 more for the same $48 000 deposited, because deposits start earning sooner and interest compounds more often.
Method
Calculate the future value of each plan with its own i and n.
Compare the same quantity: final balance or interest earned.
State the difference, explain it in context, and note a limitation.
Watch out for
Using for the quarterly account.
Recommending without giving the dollar difference or a reason.
Exam tip
Comparing and justifying
For "compare", "evaluate" or "justify" questions:
- Calculate the same quantity (final balance, interest, or payment) for each option.
- State the better option in a sentence, with the difference in dollars.
- Give a reason in context (earlier deposits, more frequent compounding, higher rate) and, if asked to evaluate, a limitation: rates can change, fees and tax are ignored, and can the saver afford the deposit?
Common mistake
Common slips
- Adding the opening balance without growing it: it is , not .
- Rounding down when finding time to a goal. If 30 months falls short, the answer is 31.
- Comparing plans on different terms or with different totals and calling the bigger balance "better" without saying why.
Summary
Opening balance plus deposits: , or start the recurrence at .
Time to a goal: use a table or trial and improvement, and give the first whole period that reaches the goal.
Earlier deposits, a higher rate and more frequent compounding all increase the future value.
In a comparison, calculate for every option, state the difference, and justify in context.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.