Lesson 7 of 7 · 16 min
Choosing the right model
Decide which finance model a situation needs — compound interest, present value, future value or perpetuity — and chain them together in multi-stage problems.
What you will be able to do
- Choose between , , and from the wording of a problem.
- Solve two-stage problems, such as saving for years and then funding a perpetuity.
- Compare a perpetuity with a pension that runs out, and explain the trade-off.
By now you have four formulas for money over time. Exam questions rarely say which one to use; the marks start with choosing. Ask two questions:
- Is there a regular payment? If not, it is compound interest on a lump sum.
- Which way is the money moving, and for how long? Building up to a goal is a future value. Paying off a loan or drawing down a pension is a present value. Paying out forever is a perpetuity.
| Situation | Clue words | Model |
|---|---|---|
| A lump sum left to grow | invests $10 000, no further deposits | |
| Regular deposits building up | saves, deposits, contributes … to reach | |
| A loan repaid, or a pension that runs out | borrows, repays, withdraws … over 20 years | |
| Payments that never stop | forever, indefinitely, in perpetuity, every year from now on |
Sione wants to know how much to deposit at the end of each fortnight so that he has $12 000 in 3 years. Which formula should he use?
A council wants to invest a lump sum now so that it can give a local surf lifesaving club $5000 at the end of every year, indefinitely. Which formula finds the lump sum?
Two-stage problems. Many real plans have a saving phase and a spending phase. The end of one is the start of the other: the future value of the savings becomes the amount that funds a pension or a perpetuity. Work backwards from the goal.
Stage 1 is a future value annuity; stage 2 is a perpetuity. The amount at retirement links them.
Worked example
Save now, live on the interest later
Leila is 40. When she retires at 65 she wants an income of $2000 at the end of every month, forever, from a fund earning 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly. Until then she will save a fixed amount at the end of each month in an account paying 6% p.a. compounded monthly.
(a) How much does she need at retirement?
(b) How much must she save each month?
(c) How much of her retirement fund is interest?
Step 1: Stage 2 first: the perpetuity
, so .
Work backwards. The perpetuity tells you the goal for the savings.
Step 2: Stage 1: the savings goal
Saving for 25 years: , , and .
Step 3: Solve for the monthly saving
per month.
Step 4: Total saved and interest
She deposits . Interest .
Step 5: Interpret
More than half of Leila's retirement fund is interest. Starting at 40 and saving $721.51 a month for 25 years gives her $2000 a month for life, and the $500 000 is still there for her estate.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $500 000. (b) $721.51 a month. (c) $283 547 of the $500 000 is interest.
Method
Identify each stage and its model.
Work backwards: the perpetuity gives the amount needed at retirement.
That amount is the future value goal for the savings stage.
Watch out for
Using the retirement rate (4.8%) for the savings stage. Each stage has its own rate.
Using the present value formula for the savings stage, which gives $3221.51.
Amara's savings plan reaches $120 000. She then invests it at 4% p.a. compounded quarterly as a perpetuity for a family scholarship. How much can be paid at the end of each quarter?
Worked example
Perpetuity or a 25-year pension?
Tom retires with $500 000, invested at 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly. He can take either:
- Option 1: a perpetuity, paid at the end of each month, or
- Option 2: a pension paid at the end of each month for 25 years, after which the fund is empty.
Calculate the monthly payment for each option and compare them.
Step 1: Option 1, the perpetuity
, so a month.
Step 2: Option 2, a present value annuity
and :
a month.
A pension that runs out after a fixed term is a present value annuity (Topic 1).
Step 3: Compare the payments
Option 2 pays more each month. Over 25 years it pays , against from Option 1.
Step 4: Compare what is left
After 25 years, Option 2 has nothing left. Option 1 still has the full $500 000, and keeps paying $2000 a month for as long as Tom lives, then passes to his estate.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Option 1 pays $2000 a month forever; Option 2 pays $2864.98 a month but stops after 25 years. Option 2 gives a higher income; Option 1 never runs out and keeps the $500 000 intact.
Method
Perpetuity: .
Fixed-term pension: solve for .
Compare the payment and what remains at the end.
Watch out for
Using the future value formula for the pension: Tom is drawing money out, not saving.
Exam tip
Multi-stage problems
- Label each stage and its model before calculating: "Stage 2 (perpetuity): ."
- Each stage has its own and . Rates before and after retirement are often different.
- Carry the unrounded amount from one stage to the next, or say that you used the rounded value.
- Finish with a sentence that answers the question in context.
Common mistake
Mixing up the models
- Using for savings gives a deposit that is far too big.
- Using for a pension treats withdrawals as deposits.
- Using for a pension with a fixed term ignores that the fund is meant to run out, so it overstates the amount needed.
Summary
No regular payment: . Building up: . Paying off or drawing down for a fixed term: . Forever: .
In two-stage problems, the end of one stage is the start of the next. Work backwards from the final goal.
A perpetuity pays less each period than a fixed-term pension from the same fund, but it never runs out.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.