Lesson 8: Evaluating economic management and writing the essay
Plan an analytical essay on economic management
SkillsWriting the analytical essayEvaluating economic management
Worked example
Plan a response to this question, using the scorecard in the lesson as stimulus: "To what extent did the Australian Government's fiscal policy support the achievement of price stability and full employment between 2021–22 and 2024–25?"
Step 1: Decode the question
"To what extent" asks for a decision on a scale, not yes or no. The focus is fiscal policy (not the RBA), two objectives (price stability, full employment) and a fixed period.
Step 2: Choose two criteria and a thesis
Criteria: effectiveness in meeting the two objectives, and appropriateness to the cycle (did the stance fit the phase?). Thesis: "Fiscal policy largely supported both objectives: contractionary while the economy was at its peak, it helped the RBA bring inflation down without a large rise in unemployment, though the return to expansionary budgets in 2024–25 added to demand while underlying inflation was still above the band."
Step 3: Plan the analysis
(1) The cycle: peak in 2022, slowdown in 2023–24 (scorecard, a cycle diagram). (2) The stance each year: contractionary in 2021–22 and 2022–23, mildly expansionary in 2023–24, expansionary in 2024–25 (budget balance, % of GDP). (3) The trade-off: inflation from 6.2% to 2.1% with unemployment from 3.6% to only 4.3% (Phillips curve).
Step 4: Plan the evaluation
Criterion 1: effectiveness, with evidence for (the outcomes) and against (the RBA did most of the work; world shocks unwound). Criterion 2: appropriateness: a contractionary stance at the peak fits; an expansionary one in 2024–25 is debatable (cost-of-living relief and tax cuts versus inflation still being brought down). A second perspective: households with mortgages and renters bore much of the adjustment.
Step 5: Conclusion
Restate the decision with its strongest reason, and what it implies for the next phase.
Answer
A plan with a scaled thesis ("largely supported"), two named criteria, three analysis paragraphs each tied to stimulus and a diagram, an evaluation that weighs evidence and perspectives against each criterion, and a conclusion that restates the decision.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Decode: the verb, the focus, the period.
Thesis with a scale; two criteria named.
Analysis: trends and relationships, each with stimulus.
Evaluation: each criterion, evidence for and against, perspectives.
Watch out for
Writing about the RBA's decisions as if they were the government's.
A thesis that only restates the question.