Lesson 8: Trade agreements, trade creation and trade diversion
Trade creation or trade diversion?
SkillTrade creation and diversion
Worked example
In an illustrative market, Australia's demand is and domestic supply (Q in thousand units). The rest of the world can supply any amount at $40 a unit and a partner country at $45. Australia charges a $10 tariff on all imports. It then signs a free trade agreement with the partner.
Decide whether the agreement creates or diverts trade, and calculate the gain from trade creation, the cost of trade diversion and the net effect.
Step 1: Before the agreement
With the tariff, the rest of the world sells at and the partner at . Australia imports from the rest of the world at $50: , , imports 40.
Step 2: After the agreement
The partner sells tariff-free at $45; the rest of the world still costs $50. Imports switch to the partner and the price falls to $45: , , imports 50.
Step 3: Identify the effect
The partner ($45) is not the lowest-cost supplier ($40), but it beats $50 because it pays no tariff: trade diversion. The price fall also creates some trade.
Step 4: Trade creation gain
Dearer home output falls by 5 and consumption rises by 5, each at a $5 saving: , that is $25 000.
Step 5: Trade diversion cost
The 40 thousand units once bought from the world at $40 now come from the partner at $45: the country pays more, $200 000 (the government also loses the $400 000 of revenue, most of which goes to consumers as a lower price).
Step 6: Net effect
: a net loss of $175 000. Consumers gain, but the country as a whole is worse off.
Answer
Trade diversion: imports switch from the lowest-cost supplier ($40) to the partner ($45). Creation gain $25 000, diversion cost $200 000, net loss $175 000.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare tariff-inclusive prices before, and partner (tariff-free) against world (with tariff) after.
Diversion if the new source is not the lowest-cost supplier.
Creation gain = the two triangles; diversion cost = (partner cost − world cost) × imports switched.
Watch out for
Calling it trade creation because consumers pay less.