Lesson 7: Protection or free trade: weighing the arguments
What does each protected job cost?
SkillsArguing protection and free tradeTariff diagrams and calculations
Worked example
An illustrative study estimates that a tariff on imported steel keeps 400 jobs in the domestic industry. Each year consumers lose $150 million of surplus, domestic producers gain $60 million and the government collects $70 million in revenue. The average wage in the industry is $95 000.
(a) Calculate the cost to consumers per job kept and the net cost to the economy per job kept. (b) Use your answers to evaluate the tariff on the criteria of efficiency and living standards.
Step 1: Cost to consumers per job
a year per job, almost four times the wage.
Step 2: Net cost to the economy
Welfare loss million. Per job: a year.
Producers' gains and the revenue are transfers within the economy; only the welfare loss is lost to everyone.
Step 3: Efficiency
The tariff wastes $20 million a year: the economy gives up $50 000 a year for each job, every year the tariff lasts.
Step 4: Living standards and viewpoints
Steel users and households pay $375 000 a year per job, while 400 workers and their towns keep incomes. If those workers could find other work quickly, paying for retraining and income support would cost far less than $375 000 each.
Step 5: Decide
On efficiency and living standards the tariff is a poor way to keep jobs: phase it out with adjustment assistance. The decision would change if the industry were strategically essential (for defence) and could not be kept another way.
Answer
(a) $375 000 per job to consumers; $50 000 per job net to the economy, each year. (b) The tariff keeps jobs at a cost far above their wages; adjustment assistance would protect the workers more cheaply, unless the industry is strategically essential.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Cost to consumers per job = consumers' loss ÷ jobs kept.
Net cost per job = (consumers' loss − producers' gain − revenue) ÷ jobs kept.
Compare with the wage and with cheaper ways to help the workers; decide with a condition.