Lesson 9: Taxes, subsidies and price controls
The Pigouvian tax when the external cost grows with output
SkillsTaxes and subsidiesExternality diagrams
Worked example
A factory's output harms a river. Demand is , the private cost is , and the external cost per unit rises with output: it is dollars per unit.
(a) Find the market and socially optimal quantities. (b) Find the per-unit Pigouvian tax and show that it brings the market to the optimum. (c) A minister proposes a tax equal to the external cost at the current output instead. What would happen?
Step 1: Market quantity
.
Step 2: Social optimum
. .
Step 3: The Pigouvian tax
External cost at : per unit. With the tax, , and .
The tax must equal the external cost of the last unit at the optimum, not at the market quantity.
Step 4: The wrong tax
External cost at : . Then , below : the tax over-corrects and creates a new welfare loss.
Answer
(a) , . (b) $22.50 per unit, which gives . (c) A $30 tax cuts output to 80, below the optimum.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
MSC = MPC + external cost; solve MSB = MSC for .
Tax = external cost per unit at .
Check: MPC + tax = MPB gives .
Watch out for
Setting the tax at the external cost at the market quantity, which over-corrects when the external cost rises with output.