Lesson 7: Environmental economics: costs, benefits and the social optimum
Environmental economics: the optimum, the tax and the welfare loss
SkillEnvironmental economics: the social optimum
Worked example
For an illustrative paper mill, and , with in thousand tonnes and costs in dollars per tonne. Waste in the river imposes an external cost of $20 per tonne.
(a) Find the market quantity and price. (b) Find the socially optimal quantity. (c) State the Pigouvian tax that would achieve it. (d) Calculate the welfare loss of the market outcome.
Step 1: Market outcome
Set : , so , thousand tonnes and .
Step 2: Social cost curve
; with no external benefit, .
Step 3: Social optimum
Set : , so thousand tonnes, at .
Step 4: Pigouvian tax
A tax equal to the external cost, $20 per tonne, raises MPC to MSC. Producers then receive per tonne, which equals at 15: .
Step 5: Welfare loss
The triangle between MSC and MSB from 15 to 20: thousand dollars, or $50 000 a year.
Answer
(a) 20 thousand tonnes at $60. (b) 15 thousand tonnes. (c) $20 per tonne. (d) $50 000.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Market: MPB = MPC. Optimum: MSB = MSC, with MSC = MPC + external cost.
Pigouvian tax = external cost per unit at the optimum.
Welfare loss = ½ × external cost × (Qₘ − Q*) for straight, parallel curves.
Watch out for
Using MPC instead of MSC to find the optimum.
Forgetting the ½ in the triangle.