Lesson 8: Environmental economics: carbon pricing, quotas and rehabilitation charges
Environmental economics: carbon tax or Safeguard Mechanism?
SkillEnvironmental economics: policy
Worked example
Source 1. Australia had a carbon price of $23 a tonne in 2012–13 and $24.15 in 2013–14. It was repealed from 1 July 2014.
Source 2. Since 1 July 2023 the Safeguard Mechanism has set declining baselines (generally 4.9% a year to 2030) for facilities emitting more than 100,000 t CO₂-e a year; facilities below their baseline earn credits they can sell.
Source 3. Emissions in the year to December 2025 were 458.9 Mt CO₂-e, 24.5% below 2005 (DCCEEW).
Evaluate whether an economy-wide carbon tax would be a more effective strategy than the Safeguard Mechanism for reaching Australia's 2030 target. Plan a full response.
Step 1: Criterion
Effectiveness (certainty of cutting emissions to the target) and efficiency (cutting at the lowest cost).
Step 2: How each works
A carbon tax fixes the price of emissions for every emitter it covers; each cuts emissions costing less than the tax. The Safeguard Mechanism fixes a declining quantity (baselines) for about 200 large facilities and lets them trade credits, so the price emerges from trading.
Step 3: Effectiveness
A tax gives certainty of price but not of quantity: if demand for energy is inelastic, emissions fall less than hoped. Declining baselines give more certainty that covered emissions fall, but they cover only large industrial facilities, not households, transport or most electricity use.
Step 4: Efficiency and equity
An economy-wide tax reaches the cheapest cuts wherever they are, and its revenue can compensate low-income households, as in 2012–14. Trading under the Safeguard Mechanism also lets cheaper cuts happen first, but only within the covered facilities.
Step 5: Durability and perspectives
Source 1 shows a carbon tax can be politically fragile; industry prefers the predictability of baselines; households worry about energy bills; future generations bear the cost of delay. Carbon leakage is a risk for trade-exposed industry under either measure.
Step 6: Decision
Judgement: on efficiency an economy-wide carbon price is superior, but on effectiveness in reaching a fixed 2030 target a quantity limit is more certain. With the falls needed (about a quarter again in five years), the best strategy keeps the Safeguard Mechanism and extends pricing to sectors it misses, rather than replacing it.
Answer
A strong response uses the sources, explains price-based against quantity-based control, weighs effectiveness, efficiency, equity and durability, presents several perspectives and makes a justified decision.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Watch out for
Describing both policies without comparing them against the criterion.