Lesson 3 of 9 · 15 min
Injections, withdrawals and equilibrium
Compare total injections with total withdrawals to decide whether national income grows, shrinks or holds steady, and explain why equilibrium does not need S = I, T = G and M = X.
What you will be able to do
- State the equilibrium condition of the circular flow: total injections equal total withdrawals.
- Decide from data whether income will rise, fall or stay the same.
- Explain why equilibrium does not require , and .
Picture a dam on a creek. Water flows in from upstream and out through the spillway. If more flows in than out, the level rises; if more flows out than in, it falls; when the two are equal, the level holds. The circular flow works the same way, with income as the level, injections as the water flowing in and withdrawals as the water flowing out.
Key idea
The equilibrium condition
- Injections greater than withdrawals: more spending enters the flow than leaves it, so businesses sell more, produce more and pay more income. Income rises.
- Injections less than withdrawals: income falls.
- Injections equal to withdrawals: the flow is in equilibrium, and income has no tendency to change.
Amounts are in $ billion a year, for an illustrative economy. Change a flow, press play and watch income move until the totals balance.
Worked example
Decide whether national income will rise or fall
In an economy in one year ($ billion): savings 140, taxation 310, imports 260, investment 190, government expenditure 290, exports 250.
(a) Calculate total withdrawals and total injections. (b) State whether national income will rise, fall or stay the same, and explain why.
Step 1: Total withdrawals
billion.
Step 2: Total injections
billion.
Step 3: Compare
Injections exceed withdrawals by billion.
Step 4: Explain the direction
More spending enters the flow than leaves it, so businesses sell more, raise output and pay more income. National income rises, and keeps rising until withdrawals (which grow with income) catch up with injections.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Withdrawals $710 billion; injections $730 billion. (b) Income rises: injections exceed withdrawals by $20 billion, so spending on output and therefore incomes grow until withdrawals rise to match.
Method
Add and .
Injections larger: income rises. Smaller: income falls. Equal: equilibrium.
Explain through spending, output and income.
Watch out for
Comparing pairs (here , , ) instead of the totals.
In a year, households save $90 billion, pay $210 billion in tax and spend $180 billion on imports. Businesses invest $140 billion, governments spend $230 billion and exports earn $150 billion. What will happen to national income?
Why income moves towards equilibrium. Withdrawals depend on income: a household with a bigger pay packet saves more, pays more tax and buys more imports. So when injections exceed withdrawals and income rises, withdrawals rise with it, and the gap closes. Income keeps rising until withdrawals have grown to match injections. When withdrawals exceed injections, income falls, withdrawals fall with it, and the flow settles at a lower level.
Key idea
Why equilibrium is not S = I, T = G and M = X
Equilibrium needs only the totals to be equal. Each pair can differ, as long as the differences cancel.
In the illustrative economy in the widget, income settles at $1000 billion with , , and , , . Saving is $50 billion below investment, but imports are $50 billion above exports. Total withdrawals and total injections are both $500 billion, so the flow is in equilibrium.
There is no reason for the pairs to match, because different people make each decision. Households decide how much to save; businesses decide how much to invest. The Treasurer sets the budget, which can be in deficit () for years. Australia's exports and imports depend on world markets, and the two have rarely been equal.
Worked example
Equilibrium with a budget deficit
An economy is in equilibrium with national income of $1,600 billion. Households save $160 billion, taxation is $320 billion and imports are $300 billion. Businesses invest $210 billion and exports are $280 billion.
(a) Calculate government expenditure. (b) Calculate the budget balance and state whether it is a surplus or a deficit. (c) Explain how the economy can be in equilibrium although , and .
Step 1: Total withdrawals
billion.
Step 2: Use the equilibrium condition
In equilibrium injections equal withdrawals: , so billion.
Step 3: Budget balance
billion, a surplus.
Tax revenue exceeds spending, so on balance the government withdraws $30 billion from the flow.
Step 4: Compare each pair
: investment exceeds saving by $50 billion (a net injection). (a net withdrawal). (a net withdrawal).
Step 5: Explain
The net withdrawals () exactly offset the net injection from investment (). Total withdrawals equal total injections, so income has no tendency to change. Equilibrium needs only the totals to balance, because different groups decide each flow.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) billion. (b) A surplus of $30 billion. (c) Investment exceeds saving by $50 billion, while the budget surplus ($30 billion) and the excess of imports over exports ($20 billion) withdraw $50 billion. The differences cancel, so total injections ($780 billion) equal total withdrawals.
Method
Find the known total, then the missing flow from .
Compare each pair to show where the differences come from.
State that only the totals must be equal.
Watch out for
Setting to find the missing flow. That assumes a balanced budget, which equilibrium does not need.
An economy is in equilibrium. Savings are $120 billion, taxation $260 billion and imports $220 billion. Investment is $170 billion and exports $190 billion. Calculate government expenditure.
Common mistake
Equilibrium is not "good"
Equilibrium means income is not changing. It says nothing about whether that level of income is high enough to employ everyone. An economy can settle in equilibrium with high unemployment, which is why governments sometimes act to raise injections.
Summary
Equilibrium in the circular flow: total injections () equal total withdrawals ().
Injections above withdrawals make income rise; below, income falls.
Because withdrawals rise and fall with income, income moves until the totals are equal.
Equilibrium does not need , or : the pairs are decided by different groups, and only the totals must match.
Equilibrium can occur with unemployment: it is a resting point, not a target.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.