Lesson 8 of 9 · 18 min
Booms, busts and the paradox of thrift
Name the phases of the economic cycle, explain how changes in the circular flow cause booms and busts and how government can smooth them, and use the flow to explain the paradox of thrift.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the phases of the economic cycle: expansion, peak, contraction and trough.
- Explain booms and busts as changes in injections and withdrawals.
- Explain how the government can minimise fluctuations in the economic cycle.
- Explain the paradox of thrift as a fallacy of composition, using the circular flow.
Over the long run Australia's output grows: more people, more capital and better technology. But it does not grow smoothly. Some years spending races ahead, jobs are easy to find and prices rise quickly; in others spending stalls, businesses cut back and unemployment climbs. These ups and downs around the long-run trend are the economic cycle (or business cycle).
The economic cycle: real GDP fluctuates around its long-run trend.
| Phase | What happens to the flow | Typical signs |
|---|---|---|
| Expansion (recovery, upswing) | Injections exceed withdrawals; spending and income grow | Rising GDP, falling unemployment, growing business confidence |
| Peak (boom) | Spending runs ahead of what the economy can produce | Very low unemployment, rising inflation, labour and materials shortages |
| Contraction (downswing) | Withdrawals exceed injections; spending and income shrink | Slowing or falling GDP, rising unemployment, falling confidence |
| Trough (bust, possibly a recession) | The flow is at its lowest point before recovery | Output falls, high unemployment, low inflation, idle capacity |
Why the economy cycles. Injections such as investment and exports are volatile. When businesses are confident they invest heavily, and the extra income makes households confident too, so they spend more and save less. The flow expands, sometimes faster than the economy can produce, and prices rise: a boom. When confidence breaks, or interest rates rise, or a major trading partner slows, investment and exports fall and households save more. Withdrawals exceed injections and the flow contracts: a bust. A severe contraction is a recession, often taken to mean two quarters in a row of falling real GDP.
Match each description to the phase of the economic cycle.
Key idea
How government can smooth the cycle
Because booms and busts are swings in the circular flow, the government and the RBA can lean against them by changing injections and withdrawals:
- In a downturn: raise government spending or cut taxes (a net injection), and the RBA cuts the cash rate so saving falls and borrowing rises.
- In a boom: restrain spending or raise taxes, and the RBA raises the cash rate, to slow spending and inflation.
- Automatic stabilisers work without any decision: in a downturn, tax collections fall and unemployment payments rise as incomes drop, which cushions household spending; in a boom the reverse slows it.
Unit 4 studies these policies in depth. For now the idea is that changing the flows on purpose can make the swings smaller.
Worked example
Read the 2020 recession from GDP data
The table shows Australia's real GDP growth on the previous quarter (ABS, Australian National Accounts, seasonally adjusted).
| Quarter | Dec 2019 | Mar 2020 | Jun 2020 | Sep 2020 | Dec 2020 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real GDP growth (%) | 0.6 | −0.2 | −6.8 | 3.4 | 3.4 |
(a) Identify the phase of the economic cycle in the June quarter 2020 and the second half of 2020, with evidence. (b) The unemployment rate rose from 5.1% in February 2020 to 7.4% in June 2020. Use the circular flow to explain why. (c) Between March and November 2020 the RBA cut the cash rate target from 0.75% to 0.10%, and the federal budget recorded a deficit of $134.2 billion in 2020–21. Explain how these responses aimed to minimise the downturn.
Step 1: (a) The June quarter 2020
Real GDP fell in two consecutive quarters (−0.2% and −6.8%): a recession. The June quarter 2020 was the trough.
Step 2: (a) The second half of 2020
Growth of 3.4% in each of the September and December quarters shows expansion (recovery).
Step 3: (b) Unemployment
In 2020, spending (consumption, investment and exports of services such as tourism and education) fell sharply. With withdrawals exceeding injections, businesses sold and produced less, so they needed fewer workers and unemployment rose.
Step 4: (c) The cash rate
A cut of percentage points (65 basis points) lowered borrowing costs and the reward for saving, encouraging consumption and investment and lowering the savings withdrawal.
Step 5: (c) The budget
A deficit means government spending exceeded tax revenue: a net injection of $134.2 billion (6.4% of GDP) in 2020–21. Payments to keep workers attached to their employers and support incomes kept households spending, replacing some of the lost private spending.
Raising injections and lowering withdrawals in a downturn makes the contraction smaller and the recovery faster.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) The June quarter 2020 was the trough of a recession (two quarters of falling real GDP); the second half of 2020 was expansion. (b) Spending fell, so withdrawals exceeded injections; businesses cut output and jobs. (c) Cutting the cash rate by 65 basis points encouraged spending and discouraged saving; the $134.2 billion deficit was a large net injection that replaced lost spending.
Method
Two consecutive quarters of negative growth indicate a recession; the lowest point is the trough.
Explain changes in jobs through spending, output and the circular flow.
Explain policy as raising injections and lowering withdrawals in a downturn.
Watch out for
Calling the September quarter 2020 a boom because growth was high. It was recovery from a deep trough.
The paradox of thrift. Saving is wise for a household: it builds a buffer against hard times. So when a downturn begins and people fear for their jobs, many households save more. What happens when they all do it at once?
Households plan to save a larger share of their income. Run it and watch income, consumption and total saving.
Key idea
The paradox of thrift
When all households try to save more, they spend less. One household's spending is another's income, so incomes fall. With lower incomes, households can save less than they planned, and income keeps falling until total saving is back where it was. If businesses also cut investment as sales fall, total saving ends up lower than before.
It is a fallacy of composition: what is true for one household (saving more makes it better off) is not true for all households together (everyone saving more makes the economy poorer and does not raise total saving).
The circular flow shows why. Saving is a withdrawal. A rise in planned saving, with injections unchanged, makes withdrawals exceed injections, so income falls. Income stops falling only when withdrawals are back down to the level of injections, and since investment has not risen, total saving cannot stay higher. The economy ends with lower income, lower consumption and more unemployment, while households have saved no more in total.
Worked example
Show the paradox of thrift with numbers
A closed economy has no government. Investment is $120 billion a year and does not change. Households save 15% of their income.
(a) Find the equilibrium level of national income. (b) Worried about a downturn, households decide to save 20% of their income. Find the new equilibrium income and total saving. (c) Explain why this result is called the paradox of thrift.
Step 1: The equilibrium condition here
The only withdrawal is saving and the only injection is investment, so equilibrium needs , that is .
In a two-sector economy with a financial sector only, injections equal withdrawals reduces to S = I.
Step 2: Starting income
billion. Saving is billion.
Step 3: New income
Now , so billion.
Step 4: New total saving
billion: unchanged.
Step 5: Explain the paradox
Each household saved a larger share, but spending fell, so incomes fell by $200 billion until saving was back to the level of investment. The attempt to save more left total saving the same and the economy poorer.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) $800 billion. (b) Income falls to $600 billion and total saving stays at $120 billion. (c) Saving more is sensible for one household, but when all households do it, spending and income fall, so total saving does not rise: a fallacy of composition.
Method
Write the equilibrium condition (here , with a share of income).
Solve for income before and after the change.
Compare total saving and income, and name the fallacy of composition.
Watch out for
Calculating new saving as 20% of the old income ($160 billion). Income falls, so 20% of the new income is still $120 billion.
In a closed economy with no government, investment is fixed at $100 billion and households save 10% of income, so income settles at $1000 billion. Households then decide to save 20% of their income. Investment stays at $100 billion. At the new equilibrium, what is total saving?
Common mistake
The paradox does not mean saving is bad
Saving funds investment, and investment builds future output. The paradox is about a sudden rise in saving by everyone at once, especially in a downturn, when businesses do not want to borrow and invest the extra savings. It is an argument for why government spending can help in a recession, not an argument against saving.
Summary
The economic cycle is the rise and fall of activity around its trend: expansion, peak (boom), contraction and trough (bust).
Booms and busts are swings in the circular flow: injections (especially investment and exports) and saving are volatile.
Government spending and taxes, the RBA cash rate and automatic stabilisers can lean against the cycle.
The paradox of thrift: when everyone tries to save more, income falls and total saving is no higher (lower if investment falls).
It is a fallacy of composition: what is wise for one household is harmful when all do it at once.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.