Lesson 6: Analysing yield and rate data
Use yield data to justify the Haber conditions
SkillsAnalysing yield and rate dataChoosing conditions for yield and rate
Worked example
The table shows the equilibrium percentage of ammonia for a mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen.
| Temperature (°C) | 100 atm | 200 atm | 300 atm |
|---|---|---|---|
| 350 | 38 | 52 | 61 |
| 450 | 16 | 27 | 36 |
| 550 | 7 | 13 | 19 |
A student proposes running a plant at and "because the data show this gives the highest yield". Evaluate the proposal.
Step 1: Confirm what the data show
At the yield rises from 19 % at to 61 % at ; at it rises from 38 % at to 61 % at . The student is right that and gives the highest equilibrium yield in the table.
Step 2: Explain the trends
The forward reaction is exothermic, so a lower temperature shifts the equilibrium to the right. It also forms fewer moles of gas, so a higher pressure shifts it to the right.
Step 3: Identify what the data do not show
The table gives yields at equilibrium. It says nothing about how quickly equilibrium is reached. At the rate is much lower, even with an iron catalyst, so less ammonia would be made per hour in a reactor where the gases stay only seconds.
In a flow reactor with recycling, the mass of ammonia per hour matters more than the equilibrium yield.
Step 4: Consider cost and safety of the pressure
Going from to at raises the yield from 27 % to 36 % per pass. But the plant recycles its unreacted gas, so a higher yield per pass is not essential, while compressing to 50 % more pressure raises the compressor energy, the cost of thicker-walled equipment and the risk of a leak or rupture.
Step 5: Reach a judgement
The proposal maximises the equilibrium yield but ignores rate, cost and safety. A temperature around and about , with unreacted gases recycled, produces more ammonia per hour at an acceptable cost, so it is the better choice.
Answer
The proposal gives the highest equilibrium yield (61 %), but the rate at is too low, and adds cost and risk for a gain that recycling makes unnecessary; about and with recycling is the better compromise.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Quote data with numbers to describe both trends.
Explain each trend with Le Châtelier's principle.
Say what the data cannot show (rate, cost, safety).
Make a clear judgement and justify it.
Watch out for
Accepting "highest yield" as "best" without considering rate.
Describing a trend without quoting any data.