Lesson 10: Atom economy and green chemistry
Compare the atom economy of two routes to ethanol
SkillAtom economy and green chemistry
Worked example
Ethanol can be made by fermentation, , or by hydration of ethene, . Calculate the atom economy of each route, and the mass of carbon dioxide produced for every tonne of ethanol made by fermentation. Use the results to comment on the two routes.
Step 1: Molar masses from the data book
, , , , .
Step 2: Atom economy of fermentation
Two moles of ethanol form from one mole of glucose, so the desired product's mass is .
Step 3: Atom economy of hydration
As for every addition reaction, ethanol is the only product.
Step 4: Carbon dioxide per tonne of ethanol
The mole ratio of to ethanol is , so the mass ratio is . Each tonne of ethanol comes with of .
Step 5: Comment
Hydration wastes no atoms, while almost half the mass of glucose leaves as . But atom economy is not the whole story: fermentation uses a renewable feedstock, runs at 35 °C and atmospheric pressure, and its was recently absorbed by photosynthesis, while hydration uses ethene from fossil fuels at 300 °C and 6–7 MPa.
Answer
Fermentation , hydration ; fermentation releases of per tonne of ethanol. Hydration is greener by atom economy, fermentation by feedstock and energy use.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Atom economy = M(desired product) × its coefficient ÷ total M of reactants × coefficients × 100 %.
Addition reactions: 100 %.
Weigh atom economy against feedstock, energy and by-product value.
Watch out for
Forgetting the coefficient 2 for ethanol (giving 25.6 %).
Treating a high atom economy as a high percentage yield.