Lesson 7: Strong, weak, concentrated and dilute
Identify five solutions from pH and conductivity
SkillStrong, weak, concentrated and dilute
Worked example
Five unlabelled solutions are known to be hydrochloric acid, ethanoic acid, hydrochloric acid, ammonia and sodium hydroxide. A student measures each one.
| Solution | pH | Conductivity | Reaction with magnesium |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | low | slow bubbling | |
| Q | high | none | |
| R | high | rapid bubbling | |
| S | low | very slow bubbling | |
| T | low | none |
Identify each solution, and explain how P and S can have similar pH values and conductivities.
Step 1: Sort acids from bases
P, R and S have pH below 7 and react with magnesium: acids. Q and T have pH above 7: bases.
Step 2: Identify the bases
Q (pH , high conductivity) is fully dissociated: , pOH . Q is sodium hydroxide. T (pH , low conductivity) is only partly ionised: ammonia.
Step 3: Identify the strong concentrated acid
R has pH , so : fully ionised at . R is HCl.
Step 4: Separate P and S
S has pH , exactly what of a fully ionised acid gives: S is HCl, strong but dilute. P is ethanoic acid, weak but concentrated: only about ionised, so and pH .
pH and conductivity depend on the concentration of ions, which is set by both concentration and strength.
Step 5: Explain the similarity
Both P and S contain about of and of anions. In S it is because there is little acid, all ionised; in P because there is a lot of acid, only slightly ionised. Similar ion concentrations give similar pH, conductivity and rate.
Answer
P ethanoic acid; Q sodium hydroxide; R HCl; S HCl; T ammonia. P (weak, concentrated) and S (strong, dilute) have similar and ion concentrations.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
pH below or above 7 separates acids from bases.
Compare pH with : equal means fully ionised (strong).
Low conductivity means few ions: weak, or dilute, or both.
Watch out for
Assuming the lowest conductivity must be the weak acid. A dilute strong acid can conduct as poorly.