Lesson 11: Acid–base indicators
Choose an indicator for titrating vinegar
SkillChoosing an indicator
Worked example
Diluted vinegar (ethanoic acid) is titrated with sodium hydroxide. The titration curve shows a steep rise from about pH to pH , with the equivalence point at pH .
Using the data book, (a) choose a suitable indicator and (b) explain why methyl orange would be unsuitable.
Step 1: Match the range to the equivalence pH
Phenolphthalein changes colour over pH –. That range contains the equivalence pH of and lies within the steep section, so it changes colour within a drop of equivalence. Phenolphthalein is suitable.
The end point (colour change) must coincide with the equivalence point.
Step 2: Check methyl orange
Methyl orange changes over pH –. On this curve, that pH is reached in the buffer region, after only a few millilitres of base, long before the equivalence point.
Step 3: Explain the consequence
With methyl orange, the end point would come far too early. The titre would be much too small, and the calculated acid concentration far too low.
Answer
(a) Phenolphthalein, whose range (–) contains the equivalence pH and lies on the steep section. (b) Methyl orange changes at pH –, in the buffer region, so the end point would come long before equivalence and the titre would be too small.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Ethanoic acid titrated with , with the colour-change ranges of methyl orange (lower band) and phenolphthalein (upper band).
Method
Find the equivalence pH and the steep section of the curve.
Pick the indicator whose range lies within the steep section (ideally containing the equivalence pH).
Explain unsuitable choices by where their range falls on the curve.
Watch out for
Choosing by colour, or always choosing an indicator with near 7.