Lesson 8: Investigating rates, from disappearing crosses to rusting iron
Protecting a steel hull from corrosion
SkillCorrosion and its prevention
Worked example
A steel fishing boat moored in Moreton Bay has blocks of zinc bolted to its hull below the waterline. The owner wants to replace a corroded steel propeller shaft fitting with a bronze (mostly copper) one, and asks whether painting the hull would make the zinc blocks unnecessary.
(a) Explain why seawater corrodes steel faster than fresh water.
(b) Explain how the zinc blocks protect the hull, and why they must be replaced every year or so.
(c) Evaluate the owner's two ideas.
Step 1: Why seawater is worse
Rusting is a redox reaction between iron, oxygen and water. Dissolved salts make seawater a good electrical conductor, so ions and electrons move more easily between the places where iron is oxidised and oxygen is reduced. The reaction is faster.
Step 2: How the zinc protects the hull
Zinc is more reactive than iron, so when the two metals are in contact in seawater, zinc is oxidised in preference to iron: . The electrons flow into the steel, so the iron is not oxidised. This is sacrificial protection.
Step 3: Why replace the blocks
The zinc is used up as it is oxidised, so the blocks wear away. Once they are gone the steel corrodes again.
Step 4: Evaluate the bronze fitting
Copper is less reactive than iron. Joined to the steel in seawater, it makes the iron the metal that is oxidised, so the steel around the fitting would corrode faster. Not a good idea unless the metals are electrically insulated from each other.
Step 5: Evaluate painting
Paint is a barrier that stops water and oxygen reaching the steel, so it slows corrosion greatly. But paint is easily scratched or chipped on a working boat, and the exposed steel then corrodes. Using paint and the zinc blocks is better than either alone; the paint also makes the zinc last longer.
Answer
(a) Dissolved salts make seawater conduct, speeding the redox reaction. (b) Zinc is more reactive, so it is oxidised instead of the iron; it is consumed, so it must be replaced. (c) A copper-based fitting would speed the corrosion of the nearby steel; paint is a useful barrier but fails where it is damaged, so keep the zinc blocks as well.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify the reactants needed for corrosion and what speeds the reaction.
Compare reactivities to decide which metal is oxidised.
Evaluate: strength, limitation, judgement.
Watch out for
Saying the zinc "repels" water. It works by being oxidised instead of the iron.
Thinking any metal coating protects steel. A less reactive metal makes corrosion worse wherever the coating is broken.