Lesson 5: Energy profile diagrams and activation energy
Why some reactions are instant and others barely happen
SkillActivation energy and bonds
Worked example
When silver nitrate solution is added to sodium chloride solution, a white precipitate forms instantly: . A mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen, , shows no measurable reaction at room temperature, even though the reaction is exothermic. Explain the difference in terms of bonds, activation energy and collisions. Use the data book's bond enthalpies.
Step 1: Identify the bonds that must break
The ionic reaction joins oppositely charged ions that attract each other; no covalent bonds need to break. The ammonia synthesis must break (, one of the strongest bonds there is) and three bonds ( each).
Step 2: Link bonds to activation energy
With no bonds to break, for the precipitation is close to zero. Breaking or substantially weakening a triple bond requires a very large activation energy.
Colliding particles must reach the transition state, where reactant bonds are partly broken. The stronger and more numerous those bonds, the higher that state lies.
Step 3: Link activation energy to successful collisions
Almost every collision between and ions succeeds, so the reaction is over as the solutions mix. At room temperature, almost no – collisions have enough energy to reach the high , so successful collisions are extremely rare.
Step 4: Note what ΔH does not tell you
Being exothermic does not make a reaction fast; and are independent. Industry makes ammonia fast enough only by using an iron catalyst at about 450 °C.
Answer
The precipitation breaks no covalent bonds, so its is tiny and almost every ionic collision succeeds: it is instantaneous. Ammonia synthesis must break the very strong bond and three bonds, so its is very high and almost no collisions succeed at room temperature: the rate is negligible.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
List the bonds that must break, with their bond enthalpies.
More and stronger bonds → higher .
Higher → smaller fraction of successful collisions → slower.
Watch out for
Saying the ammonia reaction is slow because it is exothermic.
Treating as the total bond enthalpy of the reactants; it is related to it, but much smaller, because new bonds start forming as old ones break.