Lesson 2: Polar bonds and polar molecules
Which chloromethanes are polar?
SkillPolar and non-polar molecules
Worked example
Methane, , chloromethane, , dichloromethane, , trichloromethane, , and tetrachloromethane, , are all roughly tetrahedral. Determine which of them are polar molecules, and justify your answer.
Step 1: Find the bond polarities
C–H: (weakly polar, C ). C–Cl: (polar, Cl ).
The two kinds of bond have different dipoles, so a molecule containing both cannot have all its bond dipoles equal.
Step 2: Consider and
Four identical bonds at 109.5° in a regular tetrahedron: the four equal bond dipoles cancel. Both are non-polar.
Step 3: Consider the mixed molecules
In , and the outer atoms are not all the same. The C–Cl dipoles pull electron density towards the Cl atoms, and nothing on the other side balances them, so the bond dipoles do not cancel. All three are polar.
Answer
, and are polar; and are non-polar, because only a tetrahedron with four identical outer atoms is symmetric enough for the bond dipoles to cancel.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Find each bond's polarity.
A symmetric shape cancels the dipoles only if the outer atoms are identical.
Any substitution that breaks the symmetry gives a polar molecule.
Watch out for
Calling polar because it has four polar bonds.
Calling non-polar because "the two Cl atoms balance the two H atoms". In 3D, the two Cl atoms are on the same side of the molecule.