Lesson 6: Analysing chromatograms with values
Matching the ink on a forged note
SkillsChromatograms and valuesHow chromatography separates
Worked example
Ink from a forged note (N) and from pens belonging to three suspects (X, Y and Z) were run side by side on one sheet of chromatography paper in the same solvent. The solvent front moved 9.0 cm.
| Sample | Spot distances from the baseline (cm) |
|---|---|
| Note N | 1.8, 4.5, 7.2 |
| Pen X | 1.8, 7.2 |
| Pen Y | 1.8, 4.5, 7.2 |
| Pen Z | 4.5, 6.3 |
(a) Calculate the value of each spot in the note's ink.
(b) Which pen's ink is consistent with the note? Justify your answer.
(c) A detective says the chromatogram proves suspect Y wrote the note. Evaluate this claim, and suggest how the evidence could be strengthened.
Step 1: Calculate the values (a)
, , .
Step 2: Compare each pen (b)
Pen X has spots at 0.20 and 0.80 but is missing the 0.50 component. Pen Z has spots at 0.50 and 0.70; it lacks 0.20 and 0.80 and has an extra component. Pen Y has spots at 0.20, 0.50 and 0.80, matching all three of the note's components and nothing extra.
Step 3: Weigh the evidence (c)
The match shows that pen Y's ink is consistent with the note: the note could have been written with that pen. It does not prove it. Every pen of the same brand and model would contain the same ink, and a different ink with components of the same values in this solvent would give the same pattern.
Chromatography compares; it shows two samples behave identically under these conditions. Identity needs evidence that rules out other sources.
Step 4: Strengthen the evidence
Repeat the chromatography with a second, different solvent (or TLC) to check the components still match; analyse the inks by HPLC, which compares retention times and amounts more precisely; and combine the chemistry with other evidence, such as handwriting analysis or whether other people had access to the same kind of pen.
Answer
(a) 0.20, 0.50 and 0.80. (b) Pen Y: it has the same three components (same values) as the note and no others; X lacks one and Z differs. (c) The claim overstates the evidence: the match shows Y's ink is consistent with the note, not that Y wrote it, since any pen with the same ink would match. Repeating in another solvent, HPLC analysis and independent evidence would strengthen it.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate every value.
A match needs every component to agree, with nothing extra.
When evaluating a claim, separate "consistent with" from "proves", and suggest specific further tests.
Watch out for
Choosing pen X because two of its spots match. A match needs all the components.
Accepting the detective's claim. Chromatography shows the ink could be the same, not who used it.