Lesson 12: Blood, water quality and water treatment
Evaluating the health of a creek
SkillAcid rain, blood and water quality
Worked example
A Year 11 class sampled a suburban creek at 2 pm, two days after heavy rain. Their results: water temperature 26 °C, pH 6.1, dissolved oxygen , turbidity 45 NTU, electrical conductivity (normal for this creek). At 26 °C, water saturated with air holds about of oxygen.
Evaluate the water quality of the creek for aquatic life, and suggest what further data would make the evaluation more reliable.
Step 1: Evaluate pH
pH 6.1 is slightly acidic, a little below the 6.5–8.0 suited to most freshwater life. Decaying organic matter washed in by the rain releases carbon dioxide and organic acids, which could lower it.
Step 2: Evaluate dissolved oxygen
saturation, and is well below the roughly fish need. Warm water holds less oxygen, and bacteria decomposing organic matter use it up.
Step 3: Evaluate turbidity
45 NTU is high: suspended sediment from runoff blocks light for water plants (less photosynthesis, less oxygen), clogs gills and smothers habitats.
Step 4: Evaluate conductivity
Conductivity is normal for this creek, so the rain did not bring an unusual load of dissolved salts.
Step 5: Make a judgement
Overall the creek is under stress: the low dissolved oxygen is the most serious problem, made worse by high turbidity and slightly acidic water, all consistent with stormwater runoff.
Step 6: Suggest further data
One sample after rain may not be typical. Repeat sampling at several sites and times (including early morning, when DO is lowest), and measure nitrate, phosphate and E. coli to identify fertiliser or sewage runoff.
Answer
The creek's water quality is poor for aquatic life at the time of sampling: dissolved oxygen is very low (about 47 % saturation, below about ), turbidity is high, and the pH is slightly acidic, consistent with stormwater runoff carrying sediment and organic matter. Conductivity is normal. More samples over time and at several sites, plus nutrient and E. coli tests, are needed for a reliable conclusion.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare each measurement with a guideline or healthy range.
Explain what each comparison suggests, and its likely cause.
Make an overall judgement, then evaluate the reliability of the data.
Watch out for
Listing the numbers without comparing them to anything.
Making a judgement from one measurement and ignoring the others.