Lesson 1: Why water is so unusual
Why water boils so much higher than hydrogen sulfide
SkillWater and hydrogen bonding
Worked example
Water, (), boils at 100 °C. Hydrogen sulfide, (), has the same bent shape but boils at −60 °C. Explain the difference in terms of the intermolecular forces in each substance.
Step 1: Say what boiling involves
Boiling separates molecules from each other. The higher the boiling point, the stronger the intermolecular forces that must be overcome. The covalent bonds within the molecules do not break.
Step 2: Compare the dispersion forces
has more electrons than , so its dispersion forces are slightly stronger. On dispersion forces alone, should boil higher.
Dispersion forces grow with the number of electrons. This rules them out as the reason water boils higher.
Step 3: Identify hydrogen bonding in water
Oxygen (electronegativity 3.4) is much more electronegative than hydrogen (2.2), and it is small with two lone pairs. Each δ+ hydrogen on one water molecule is strongly attracted to a lone pair on the oxygen of a neighbour: a hydrogen bond. Each molecule can form up to four.
Step 4: Explain why hydrogen sulfide cannot hydrogen bond
Sulfur (2.6) is only slightly more electronegative than hydrogen (2.2), and it is larger, so the S–H bond is only weakly polar. has weak dipole–dipole attractions and dispersion forces, but no hydrogen bonds.
Hydrogen bonding needs H bonded directly to N, O or F.
Step 5: Conclude
Hydrogen bonds are much stronger than the dipole–dipole forces in , so far more energy is needed to separate water molecules. Water therefore boils about 160 °C higher.
Answer
Water molecules are held together by hydrogen bonds (a δ+ H on one molecule attracted to a lone pair on the very electronegative O of another, up to four per molecule). Hydrogen sulfide has only weak dipole–dipole and dispersion forces because S is not electronegative enough to form hydrogen bonds. Much more energy is needed to overcome water's hydrogen bonds, so water boils at a much higher temperature despite its smaller molar mass.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Boiling overcomes intermolecular forces, not covalent bonds.
Identify the strongest intermolecular force in each substance.
Compare their strengths and link to the energy needed.
Watch out for
Saying the O–H bonds are stronger than S–H bonds, so water is harder to boil. Boiling does not break covalent bonds.
Forgetting to explain why does not hydrogen bond.