Lesson 9: Strong, weak, concentrated and dilute
Hydrochloric and ethanoic acids of the same concentration
SkillsStrength, concentration and ArrheniusThe pH scale
Worked example
A student measures the pH of hydrochloric acid as 1.0 and of ethanoic acid as 2.9.
(a) Use the Arrhenius model, with equations, to explain the difference.
(b) Estimate the percentage of ethanoic acid molecules that are ionised.
(c) Predict how the two acids compare in electrical conductivity, in the rate of reaction with magnesium ribbon, and in the volume of sodium hydroxide solution needed to neutralise 25.0 mL of each.
Step 1: Write the ionisation equations
(complete) and (partial).
Step 2: Explain the pH difference
Both are Arrhenius acids, producing in water. Hydrochloric acid is strong: every molecule ionises, so and pH = 1.0. Ethanoic acid is weak: only a small fraction ionises, so is much lower and the pH is higher.
Step 3: Calculate the fraction ionised
, so the percentage ionised is .
Each ionised molecule releases one hydrogen ion, so the fraction ionised is the hydrogen ion concentration divided by the acid's concentration.
Step 4: Compare conductivity and rate
Hydrochloric acid has about 80 times the hydrogen ion concentration () and far more ions in total, so it conducts electricity much better and reacts much faster with magnesium (more collisions per second).
Step 5: Compare neutralisation
Both contain the same amount of acid, , so they need the same volume of sodium hydroxide. As removes , more ethanoic acid molecules ionise until all have reacted.
Answer
(a) ionises completely, only partly, so is much lower in ethanoic acid. (b) about 1.3 % (c) conducts better and reacts faster with magnesium; both need the same volume of .
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Strong: complete ionisation, single arrow. Weak: partial, equilibrium arrow.
Percentage ionised for a monoprotic acid.
Rate and conductivity depend on ; the amount of base depends on the total moles of acid.
Watch out for
Predicting that the weak acid needs less sodium hydroxide.
Calling ethanoic acid "dilute" because its pH is higher. It has the same concentration as the hydrochloric acid.