Lesson 3: Ionic lattices and metallic bonding
Telling ionic from metallic from data
SkillsIonic and metallic bondingClassifying substances from data
Worked example
Two white or silvery solids, P and Q, were tested.
| Property | P | Q |
|---|---|---|
| Melting point (°C) | 660 | 770 |
| Conducts as a solid | yes | no |
| Conducts when molten | yes | yes |
| Effect of hammering | flattens | shatters |
Determine the type of bonding in each solid, giving reasons.
Step 1: Note what the data share
Both have high melting points, so both have strong forces throughout the structure. Melting point alone can't separate them.
Step 2: Use conductivity as a solid
P conducts as a solid, so it has charged particles free to move in the solid: delocalised electrons. Q does not conduct as a solid but does when molten, so its charged particles are fixed in the solid and free in the liquid: ions.
Only metals (and graphite) have mobile charge carriers in the solid. Ions become mobile only when the lattice breaks down.
Step 3: Use the mechanical properties
P flattens (malleable): layers of cations slide while the electron sea keeps them bonded. Q shatters (brittle): shifting a layer lines up like charges, which repel.
Answer
P is metallic (conducts as a solid and liquid by delocalised electrons; malleable). Q is ionic (conducts only when molten, as its ions become free to move; brittle). P fits aluminium and Q potassium chloride.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Use conductivity of the solid first.
Confirm with conductivity of the liquid and with malleability or brittleness.
Watch out for
Deciding from melting point alone.
Saying Q conducts when molten because of free electrons.