Lesson 1: Biodiversity and the species concept
One species of tree frog or two?
SkillWhat counts as a species
Worked example
Two populations of a tree frog live in the rainforests of the Wet Tropics, north and south of a dry corridor. Biologists collect this evidence.
- Frogs from the two populations look identical, even under a microscope.
- In the laboratory, crosses between the two populations produce tadpoles that develop normally into fertile adults.
- Where the populations meet, in a narrow contact zone, males of each population have a different mating call, and females move only towards their own population's call. Hybrids are rare there.
- A gene in the mitochondrial DNA differs consistently between the populations, showing they have been separate for a long time.
Evaluate whether the populations should be classified as one species or two, using the morphological, biological and phylogenetic species concepts.
Step 1: Apply the morphological species concept
The frogs look identical (evidence 1), so on physical features alone they would be one species.
The morphological concept groups organisms by shared physical features.
Step 2: Apply the biological species concept
The populations can produce fertile offspring (evidence 2), but only in the laboratory. In nature, females choose their own population's call, so the populations rarely interbreed where they meet (evidence 3). They are reproductively isolated by behaviour in natural conditions, which points to two species.
The biological concept is about interbreeding in natural populations. Laboratory crosses show what is possible, not what happens.
Step 3: Apply the phylogenetic species concept
The consistent DNA difference (evidence 4) shows two separately evolving lineages that can be told apart, so by this concept they are two species.
Step 4: Weigh the evidence and conclude
Two of the three concepts, and the strongest evidence from nature (call choice and DNA), support two species that happen to look the same: cryptic species. The morphological concept fails here because the populations have diverged in behaviour and DNA, not in appearance.
Step 5: State a limitation
The conclusion rests on one gene and one contact zone. Sequencing more genes and checking whether the rare hybrids are fertile in the wild would strengthen it.
Answer
Most of the evidence supports two cryptic species: they are reproductively isolated in nature by mate choice (biological concept) and genetically distinct (phylogenetic concept), even though they look identical (which alone would suggest one species).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Apply each species concept to the evidence it uses.
Under the biological concept, give more weight to what happens in nature than in the laboratory.
Weigh the concepts and reach a judgement.
State a limitation of the evidence.
Watch out for
Concluding "one species" because laboratory crosses are fertile. The biological concept asks about natural interbreeding.
Evaluating with only one concept. "Evaluate" asks you to weigh evidence and reach a justified judgement.