Lesson 5: Capture–recapture and the Lincoln index
Evaluate repeated capture–recapture estimates
SkillsCapture–recapture and the Lincoln indexInterpreting field data
Worked example
Bush rats (Rattus fuscipes) in a 4 ha patch of forest were sampled with Elliott traps three times, a month apart. Each time, 30 rats were caught and marked with a fur clip in the first night, and the traps were reopened two nights later.
| Trial | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 30 | 28 | 6 |
| 2 | 30 | 32 | 8 |
| 3 | 30 | 25 | 3 |
(a) Calculate the population estimate for each trial and the mean. (b) Identify the least reliable estimate and explain why. (c) Fur clips grow out over several weeks. Explain whether this affects these results. (d) Suggest one improvement.
Step 1: Calculate each estimate
Trial 1:
Trial 2:
Trial 3:
Step 2: Calculate the mean
rats.
Step 3: Identify the least reliable estimate
Trial 3 is anomalous: it is about twice the others. It rests on only marked recaptures, so one more or one fewer marked rat would change it to or . Small values of give very uncertain estimates.
Reliability is about how consistent repeated results are, and how much a small change in the data changes the answer.
Step 4: Judge the effect of fur clips growing out
Within one trial, the recapture is only two nights after marking, so clips will not have grown out and is not affected. The risk is between trials: a month later, a clip from the previous trial may not have grown out fully, so a rat clipped last month could be counted as one marked this time, making too large and too low. Clipping a different position in each trial removes the risk.
Step 5: Suggest an improvement
Increase the number of traps and nights so that and (and so ) are larger, reducing the effect of chance; or use a mark unique to each trial (different clip positions).
Answer
(a) 140, 120 and 250; mean 170 rats (or about 130 without the anomalous trial 3, if that is justified). (b) Trial 3: is so small that the estimate is very uncertain. (c) Not within a trial: recapture was two nights after marking, too soon for clips to grow out. But a clip left from the previous month could be mistaken for a new one, so each trial needs its own mark. (d) Larger samples (more traps or nights) so that is larger; distinct marks for each trial.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate each estimate before averaging.
Look for an anomaly and explain it from the data (small , an assumption broken).
Judge each assumption against the timing and method given.
Suggest an improvement that targets the specific weakness.
Watch out for
Dropping an anomalous result without giving a reason.
Saying "do more trials" without saying how it improves reliability.