Lesson 10 of 11 · 20 min
Controlling disease: hygiene, tracing, quarantine and vaccination
Explain how hygiene, contact tracing, quarantine, biosecurity and vaccination control the spread of disease, use the herd immunity threshold, and evaluate eradication programs for smallpox, polio and malaria.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how personal hygiene measures, contact tracing and quarantine break chains of transmission.
- Calculate the herd immunity threshold, , and the vaccination coverage it requires.
- Describe Australia's biosecurity system: surveillance, monitoring, examination and clearance based on risk analysis.
- Evaluate why some health programs (smallpox) eradicated a disease and others (polio, malaria) have not yet.
Every control measure works the same way at heart: it lowers the number of people each case infects. Wash your hands and fewer pathogens reach the next person. Trace and quarantine contacts and fewer infectious people are out mixing. Vaccinate and fewer people can be infected at all. Push the reproduction number below 1 and the outbreak shrinks.
| Measure | What it blocks |
|---|---|
| Washing hands with soap for at least 20 seconds, or alcohol hand rub | Contact and faecal–oral transmission: soap lifts microbes off skin, and alcohol damages their membranes and proteins. |
| Covering coughs and sneezes, wearing masks, ventilating rooms | Droplet and airborne transmission. |
| Cooking food thoroughly, keeping cold food below 5 °C, washing hands before handling food | Food-borne transmission. |
| Safe drinking water and sanitation (treated water, sewerage, boiling in emergencies) | Water-borne transmission. |
| Condoms, not sharing needles (needle and syringe programs) | Transmission through body fluids. |
| Insect repellent, long sleeves, removing standing water where mosquitoes breed | Vector-borne transmission. |
History
Hand washing in Vienna
In the 1840s, mothers in one maternity clinic at the Vienna General Hospital, staffed by doctors and medical students, died of puerperal (childbed) fever far more often than in the clinic staffed by midwives. Ignaz Semmelweis noticed that the doctors came straight from dissecting corpses. In 1847 he made them wash their hands in chlorinated lime solution, and deaths in the doctors' clinic fell from around 10 % of mothers to around 1–2 %. Germ theory had not yet been accepted, and many doctors rejected his idea.
Definition
Isolation, quarantine and contact tracing
- Isolation separates people who are sick (or have tested positive) from others while they are infectious.
- Quarantine restricts the movement of people (or animals or goods) who may have been exposed but are not yet sick, for at least the incubation period, so that if they become infectious they are not mixing with others.
- Contact tracing finds the people a case may have infected: interview each case, list their contacts during the infectious period, notify those contacts, and test and quarantine them. Each traced contact who would have become ill is a chain of transmission cut before it starts.
Contact tracing and quarantine were very effective against SARS in 2003 but much less so against the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2 in 2022. Which difference best explains this?
Key idea
The herd immunity threshold
An outbreak cannot be sustained once . Rearranging, the proportion who must be immune is
If a vaccine is only partly effective (effectiveness , as a decimal), the proportion who must be vaccinated is higher:
These come from a simple model in which everyone mixes evenly. Real populations have clusters of unvaccinated people, so outbreaks can happen in a community even when national coverage is above the threshold.
Worked example
Is measles vaccination coverage high enough?
Measles has an of about . Two doses of MMR vaccine are about effective at preventing measles.
(a) Calculate the herd immunity threshold. (b) Calculate the vaccination coverage needed to reach it. (c) A community has two-dose coverage and no other immunity. Calculate and predict what happens if measles is brought in by a traveller.
Step 1: Herd immunity threshold
, so must be immune.
Step 2: Coverage needed
, so must be vaccinated.
Only 97 % of vaccinated people are actually immune, so more than 93.3 % must be vaccinated.
Step 3: Proportion immune in the community
Step 4: Effective reproduction number
Step 5: Predict
, so each case would infect about two others on average and an outbreak would grow among the unvaccinated and the few vaccinated people who did not respond. Coverage needs to rise by about 7 percentage points to protect the community.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 93.3 %. (b) 96.2 %. (c) Rₑ ≈ 2.1, above 1, so an outbreak would spread.
Method
Herd immunity threshold: 1 − 1/R₀.
Coverage needed: divide by the vaccine effectiveness.
Proportion immune = coverage × effectiveness; Rₑ = R₀(1 − p).
Watch out for
Using the coverage (0.89) as the proportion immune without multiplying by the effectiveness.
Writing the threshold as 1/R₀ (6.7 %), the proportion that can stay susceptible.
The herd immunity threshold, , as a percentage. A highly transmissible disease needs almost everyone immune.
Whooping cough (pertussis) has an of about . Calculate its herd immunity threshold as a percentage, to the nearest whole percent.
The pathogen's is fixed here. Raise the proportion immune until falls below 1, and compare it with .
Switch on hygiene, contact tracing, quarantine and vaccination one at a time, then together. Then start them ten days later: what happens to the peak?
Key idea
Australia's biosecurity system
Australia is an island continent with no land borders, so every person, animal, plant and cargo arrives by sea or air through points that can be watched. That has kept out pests and diseases that are widespread elsewhere, such as foot-and-mouth disease and rabies. But the volume of trade, mail and travel keeps growing, so under the Biosecurity Act 2015 the system works in three places, with every decision based on scientific data and risk analysis (how likely a pest is to arrive, establish and spread, and how much harm it would do):
- Offshore (pre-border): import risk analyses set the conditions for each kind of goods; inspectors check and treat goods overseas; surveillance in neighbouring countries gives early warning.
- At the border: examination and clearance of travellers, mail and cargo: incoming passenger declarations, X-ray screening, detector dogs, inspection, and fumigation or destruction of risky material.
- Onshore (post-border): surveillance and monitoring for anything that slipped through, such as the Northern Australia Quarantine Strategy, which since 1989 has watched the Torres Strait and the north for pests and diseases arriving from the north; and emergency responses to eradicate new incursions.
When it fails, the costs are large. Red imported fire ants, detected in Brisbane in 2001, are still being fought. The varroa mite, a parasite of honey bees found at the Port of Newcastle in 2022, spread so widely that in 2023 the national eradication program was replaced by a plan to manage it.
A detector dog at Brisbane Airport finds pork sausages in a traveller's luggage from a country with foot-and-mouth disease. The sausages are seized and destroyed. Which biosecurity activity is this?
| Program | What was done | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Smallpox: WHO Intensified Eradication Programme, from 1967 | Surveillance to find every case, then ring vaccination of everyone around it, using a heat-stable freeze-dried vaccine | Last natural case in Somalia in October 1977; declared eradicated by the World Health Assembly in May 1980. The only human disease eradicated so far. |
| Polio: Global Polio Eradication Initiative, from 1988 | Mass vaccination, mainly with oral polio vaccine, and surveillance of every case of sudden paralysis and of sewage | Cases fell by more than 99 % from an estimated 350 000 a year in 1988. Wild types 2 and 3 are eradicated; wild type 1 still circulates in Pakistan and Afghanistan. |
| Malaria: national programs and WHO strategies | Insecticide-treated bed nets, indoor spraying, drugs, draining breeding sites; vaccines (RTS,S and R21) recommended for children in Africa from 2021 and 2023 | Australia was certified malaria-free by WHO in 1981, but worldwide there were an estimated 263 million cases and 597 000 deaths in 2023 (WHO World malaria report 2024). |
Worked example
Why smallpox was eradicated but malaria has not been
Smallpox was declared eradicated in 1980, about 13 years after WHO intensified its program. Malaria still caused an estimated 263 million cases in 2023 (WHO, World malaria report 2024). Evaluate the features of the two diseases that made one program succeed and make the other so difficult.
Step 1: Hosts and reservoirs
Smallpox virus infected only humans: with no animal reservoir, once every human chain was broken it had nowhere to survive. Malaria's Plasmodium lives in humans and in Anopheles mosquitoes, which breed in billions and cannot all be controlled.
Step 2: Finding cases
Smallpox caused a distinctive rash in almost everyone infected, and people were most infectious after it appeared, so every case could be found and isolated. Malaria infections can be mild or symptomless in people with partial immunity, who remain a source for mosquitoes.
Step 3: Vaccines and immunity
The smallpox vaccine was cheap, heat-stable (freeze-dried), given in one dose with a bifurcated needle and gave long-lasting immunity, so ring vaccination around each case stopped spread. Malaria vaccines (RTS,S, R21) give partial, waning protection and need several doses; natural immunity to malaria is incomplete.
Step 4: Pathogen change
Smallpox virus varied little. Plasmodium has evolved resistance to antimalarial drugs and mosquitoes to insecticides.
Step 5: Judgement
Smallpox had every feature that makes eradication feasible: one host, visible cases, an effective stable vaccine and a stable pathogen. Malaria has none of them, so its control depends on reducing transmission (bed nets, spraying, treatment) and it can be eliminated only country by country, as Australia was certified in 1981.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Smallpox infected only humans, every case was visible, and a cheap heat-stable vaccine gave lasting immunity, so surveillance and ring vaccination ended it. Malaria has a mosquito vector, symptomless carriers, only partly effective vaccines and drug and insecticide resistance, so it can be controlled and eliminated locally but not yet eradicated.
Method
Compare on the same features: hosts, ease of finding cases, vaccine, how much the pathogen changes.
"Evaluate" needs a judgement at the end, supported by the comparison.
Watch out for
Giving only the history (dates) without explaining why the biology mattered.
Saying malaria is caused by a virus or bacterium. Plasmodium is a protist.
Note
Fighting a vector with a bacterium
Aedes aegypti mosquitoes carry dengue in north Queensland. The World Mosquito Program, then based at Monash University, released mosquitoes carrying the bacterium Wolbachia, which stops the virus multiplying inside them and spreads through the mosquito population through breeding. After releases across Townsville from 2014 to 2017, no local dengue transmission was confirmed anywhere in Townsville once Wolbachia had established, after local transmission every year for the previous 13 years (O'Neill and colleagues, Gates Open Research, 2018), and releases in and around Cairns gave a similar result.
Summary
Hygiene measures each block a mode of transmission: hands, coughs, food, water, body fluids, vectors.
Isolation separates the sick; quarantine restricts the exposed; contact tracing finds and quarantines contacts before they spread it.
The herd immunity threshold is ; with vaccine effectiveness , coverage must be .
Australian biosecurity works offshore, at the border and onshore, using surveillance, monitoring, examination and clearance based on risk analysis.
Smallpox was eradicated (1980) because it had no animal host, obvious symptoms and a stable vaccine; polio and malaria are harder.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.