Lesson 8 of 11 · 18 min
Antimicrobial agents and zones of inhibition
Plan and interpret a zone of inhibition experiment testing an antimicrobial agent, and explore how First Nations knowledges of antiseptic plants are used to prevent and treat infection.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish antibiotics, antiseptics and disinfectants, and explain why antibiotics do not work against viruses.
- Describe a valid, safe zone of inhibition method, identifying the variables and controls.
- Process zone of inhibition data (means, anomalies, uncertainty) and draw a conclusion.
- Describe specific First Nations uses of antiseptic plants and what laboratory research has found about them.
In 1928 Alexander Fleming came back from holiday to find a mould growing on one of his plates of Staphylococcus. Around the mould was a clear ring where the bacteria had died. That ring, a zone of inhibition, is still how laboratories compare antimicrobial substances, and it is the investigation the syllabus asks you to analyse.
Definition
Kinds of antimicrobial agent
An antimicrobial agent kills microorganisms or stops them growing.
- Antibiotics are drugs (first found in fungi and bacteria) that kill bacteria (bactericidal) or stop them multiplying (bacteriostatic) inside the body. Penicillin blocks the building of peptidoglycan cell walls; tetracycline blocks the 70S ribosomes of bacteria.
- Antiseptics are used on living tissue such as skin and wounds: povidone-iodine, chlorhexidine, alcohol hand rub, tea tree oil.
- Disinfectants are used on non-living surfaces and are often too harsh for skin: bleach, phenol-based cleaners.
Common mistake
Antibiotics do not kill viruses
Antibiotics act on structures that only bacteria have: peptidoglycan walls, 70S ribosomes and bacterial enzymes. A virus has none of these and uses the host cell's machinery, so antibiotics have no effect on colds, influenza or COVID-19. Taking them anyway kills harmless bacteria and selects for antibiotic-resistant ones. Viral infections are treated, where treatment exists, with antiviral drugs, which target viral enzymes.
The zone of inhibition method
Prepare the lawn
Using aseptic technique, spread a broth culture of a non-pathogenic bacterium (for example Escherichia coli K-12 or Bacillus subtilis) evenly over a nutrient agar plate.
Add the discs
With sterile forceps, place filter paper discs of the same size (often 6 mm) soaked in equal volumes of each antimicrobial solution. Include a negative control disc (sterile water or the solvent alone) and a positive control (a disc with a known antibiotic).
Seal and incubate
Tape the lid on with two short strips (not sealed all the way round, so anaerobic pathogens are not encouraged), label the base, and incubate upside down at 25–30 °C for 24–48 hours. School labs do not incubate at 37 °C, the temperature that favours human pathogens.
Measure
Without opening the plate, measure the diameter of each clear zone in millimetres with a ruler across the base, at two angles at right angles, and average them.
Replicate and dispose
Repeat on at least three plates. Autoclave all plates before disposal.
| Variable | Example |
|---|---|
| Independent | The type of antimicrobial, or its concentration (for example 0, 1, 2, 5 and 10 % tea tree oil) |
| Dependent | The diameter of the zone of inhibition (mm) |
| Controlled | Species and density of the bacterial lawn; agar type, depth and age; disc size; volume of solution on each disc; incubation temperature and time; spacing of discs |
| Controls | Negative: a disc with water or solvent only (shows the solvent and disc alone have no effect). Positive: a known antibiotic (shows the bacteria were susceptible and the method works). |
Measure each zone with the ruler, record it, and compare the replicates. Which concentration gives the least reliable data?
Tea tree oil does not mix with water, so a student dissolves it in ethanol before soaking the discs. Why must one disc be soaked in ethanol alone?
Worked example
Process zone of inhibition data for tea tree oil
A student tested tea tree oil (dissolved in ethanol) on lawns of Bacillus subtilis. The table gives the diameter of each zone of inhibition, including the 6 mm disc.
| Tea tree oil (% v/v) | Plate 1 (mm) | Plate 2 (mm) | Plate 3 (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (ethanol only) | 6 | 6 | 6 |
| 1 | 9 | 10 | 9 |
| 2 | 12 | 13 | 11 |
| 5 | 16 | 15 | 22 |
| 10 | 19 | 20 | 21 |
(a) Identify the anomaly and suggest a cause. (b) Calculate the mean zone diameter and its uncertainty for each concentration. (c) Write a conclusion. (d) Explain the purpose of the 0 % discs.
Step 1: The anomaly
At , plate 3 gave , far above the other two ( and ) and even above every result. Possible causes: extra solution on that disc, the disc sliding and smearing oil, or a thinner lawn on that plate. Leave it out of the mean.
Step 2: Means and uncertainties
Uncertainty is half the range of the replicates used.
% v/v Mean (mm) Uncertainty (mm) 0 6.0 (no zone beyond the disc) ±0 1 9.3 ±0.5 2 12.0 ±1.0 5 15.5 (plates 1 and 2) ±0.5 10 20.0 ±1.0 Step 3: Conclusion
Over the range tested, the zone of inhibition increased as the concentration of tea tree oil increased, from at to at , so higher concentrations inhibited the growth of B. subtilis over a larger area. The increase is not proportional: each extra percent adds less at higher concentrations.
Step 4: Purpose of the 0 % discs
They are the negative control. The ethanol-only discs gave no zone beyond the disc itself, so the zones on the other discs are due to the tea tree oil, not the ethanol or the paper.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Plate 3 at 5 % (22 mm); for example too much solution on the disc. (b) 1 %: 9.3 ± 0.5; 2 %: 12.0 ± 1.0; 5 %: 15.5 ± 0.5; 10 %: 20.0 ± 1.0 mm. (c) Zone diameter increased with concentration over 1–10 %. (d) A negative control showing ethanol alone does not inhibit growth.
Method
Find the anomaly by comparing replicates; leave it out and say why.
Mean of the rest; uncertainty = half their range.
Conclusion: the trend, with values, within the range tested.
Watch out for
Including the anomaly in the mean, which gives 17.7 mm at 5 %.
Claiming the results show tea tree oil would cure skin infections. A plate is not a person.
Key idea
Processing the data
- Anomalies: a result that does not fit the pattern of its replicates (an unusually large zone where a disc slid, or a dried-out plate). Identify it, say why, and leave it out of the mean.
- Mean of the remaining replicates, to the precision of the ruler (usually to 0.1 mm for a mean of whole-millimetre readings).
- Uncertainty: half the range of the replicates, . Close replicates mean reliable data.
- Conclusion: state the trend between the independent and dependent variables, within the range tested, and whether it supports the hypothesis.
Common mistake
A bigger zone is not always a better antimicrobial
A zone forms where the substance has diffused through the agar at a concentration high enough to inhibit growth. A large molecule, or an oil that does not mix with the water in agar, diffuses less far, so it can give a small zone even if it is very effective. Compare zone sizes only for similar substances tested in the same way, and do not claim the results show how well an agent would work on skin or in the body.
Three replicate zones for one antiseptic measured , and . Calculate the uncertainty in the mean as half the range, in millimetres.
History
First Nations knowledges of antiseptic plants
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have used plants to prevent and treat infections for thousands of years, and that knowledge is held and passed on by communities today. Two well-documented examples:
- Tea tree (Melaleuca alternifolia). The Bundjalung people of northern New South Wales inhaled the scent of crushed tea tree leaves to treat coughs and colds, sprinkled crushed leaves on wounds before applying a poultice, and soaked leaves to make an infusion for sore throats and skin complaints (Carson, Hammer and Riley, Clinical Microbiology Reviews, 2006). Laboratory studies since have found that tea tree oil inhibits most bacteria tested at concentrations of 1 % or less, including Staphylococcus aureus, and that its main active component is terpinen-4-ol, which damages microbial membranes. The oil is now used in antiseptic creams around the world.
- Emu bush (Eremophila longifolia). In parts of inland Australia, leaves of this shrub are smouldered over embers in smoking ceremonies, for example for mothers and newborn babies after childbirth. Researchers at the University of New England (Sadgrove, Jones and colleagues, 2013–2014) found that the smoke and heated leaf oils inhibit bacteria such as Staphylococcus aureus and the yeast Candida albicans, partly because heating forms antimicrobial compounds that are not in the fresh leaves. Only plants from some regions produce them, which fits with the knowledge holders' own choice of which plants to use.
Knowledges like these belong to particular peoples and Country. Researchers increasingly work in partnership with knowledge holders, with their consent, and recognise their cultural and intellectual property in any product that results.
A student wants to test the hypothesis that crushed tea tree leaves inhibit bacterial growth more than crushed leaves of a eucalypt. Identify the independent and dependent variables, and one variable that must be controlled.
Summary
Antibiotics act on bacterial structures and do nothing against viruses; antiseptics are for living tissue, disinfectants for surfaces.
A zone of inhibition is the clear area around a disc where bacteria have not grown; measure its diameter in mm.
Use aseptic technique, a non-pathogenic bacterium, incubation at 25–30 °C, negative and positive controls and at least three replicates.
Exclude anomalies, average the replicates, and give uncertainty as half the range.
Zone size depends on diffusion as well as potency, so compare like with like.
The Bundjalung people's use of tea tree, and the smoking of emu bush leaves, are First Nations antiseptic practices that laboratory research has since supported.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.