Lesson 8: Antimicrobial agents and zones of inhibition

Process zone of inhibition data for tea tree oil

SkillZones of inhibition

Worked example

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

A student tested tea tree oil (dissolved in ethanol) on lawns of Bacillus subtilis. The table gives the diameter of each zone of inhibition, including the 6 mm disc.

Tea tree oil (% v/v)Plate 1 (mm)Plate 2 (mm)Plate 3 (mm)
0 (ethanol only)666
19109
2121311
5161522
10192021

(a) Identify the anomaly and suggest a cause. (b) Calculate the mean zone diameter and its uncertainty for each concentration. (c) Write a conclusion. (d) Explain the purpose of the 0 % discs.

1 of 4 steps
  1. Step 1: The anomaly

    At 5 %5\,\%, plate 3 gave 22 mm22\unit{mm}, far above the other two (1616 and 15 mm15\unit{mm}) and even above every 10 %10\,\% result. Possible causes: extra solution on that disc, the disc sliding and smearing oil, or a thinner lawn on that plate. Leave it out of the mean.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Find the anomaly by comparing replicates; leave it out and say why.

  2. Mean of the rest; uncertainty = half their range.

  3. Conclusion: the trend, with values, within the range tested.

Watch out for

  • Including the anomaly in the mean, which gives 17.7 mm at 5 %.

  • Claiming the results show tea tree oil would cure skin infections. A plate is not a person.

Save your progress with a free account