Lesson 7: How plants defend themselves
Interpret data on a plant defensin
SkillPlant defences
Worked example
Researchers inserted the gene for a plant defensin into a cotton variety, then sprayed leaves of normal and genetically modified (GM) plants with the same number of spores of a fungal pathogen. After 10 days they counted fungal lesions on three leaves of each.
| Plants | Leaf 1 | Leaf 2 | Leaf 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | 24 | 27 | 21 |
| GM (defensin) | 6 | 9 | 7 |
(a) Calculate the mean number of lesions per leaf for each group. (b) Calculate the percentage reduction in lesions in the GM plants. (c) Explain the result. (d) State one limitation of the data.
Step 1: Means
Normal: . GM: lesions per leaf.
Step 2: Percentage reduction
Step 3: Explain
Defensins are small, cysteine-rich antifungal proteins that damage fungal cell membranes. Leaves making more defensin killed or slowed more germinating spores, so fewer lesions formed. This is a chemical innate defence.
Step 4: Limitation
Only three leaves per group (perhaps from one plant each), so the sample is too small to be confident that the difference is not chance variation. More leaves from several plants, repeated, would improve reliability. The test also used only one fungus in one set of conditions.
Answer
(a) Normal 24.0, GM 7.3 lesions per leaf. (b) A 69 % reduction. (c) The defensin damages fungal membranes, a chemical defence. (d) For example, a small sample of three leaves.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Mean: add the replicates and divide by how many.
Percentage reduction: (old − new) ÷ old × 100.
Explain with the defence's mechanism, then judge the sample size and conditions.
Watch out for
Dividing by the GM value when calculating the percentage reduction.
Concluding that the GM cotton resists all pathogens. The data tested one fungus.