Lesson 11: Analysing outbreak data
Find the source of a food-poisoning outbreak
SkillAnalysing outbreak data
Worked example
Of 90 students and staff at a school camp, 54 developed gastroenteritis after lunch (the epidemic curve in the lesson). Investigators asked everyone what they ate.
| Food | Ate: ill | Ate: total | Did not eat: ill | Did not eat: total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken salad | 50 | 60 | 4 | 30 |
| Fried rice | 42 | 70 | 12 | 20 |
| Fruit salad | 26 | 45 | 28 | 45 |
| Juice | 49 | 80 | 5 | 10 |
(a) Calculate the attack rate for each group. (b) Determine the most likely source, with reasons. (c) Explain why the four people who did not eat chicken salad but became ill do not rule it out.
Step 1: Attack rates
Food Ate Did not eat Chicken salad Fried rice Fruit salad Juice Step 2: Compare
Only chicken salad shows a big difference: of those who ate it became ill against of those who did not, about times the risk. For the other foods the attack rates are similar whether or not people ate them.
A food eaten by many of the ill people is not enough on its own: juice was drunk by almost everyone, so it is common among the ill too. What counts is the difference between eaters and non-eaters.
Step 3: Coverage of cases
Chicken salad accounts for of the cases ().
Step 4: The four exceptions
They may have tasted it without remembering, eaten food contaminated from it (shared utensils or serving spoons), caught it from an ill person, or had gastroenteritis from another cause. Recall surveys are never perfect.
Answer
(a) Chicken salad 83 % vs 13 %; fried rice 60 % vs 60 %; fruit salad 58 % vs 62 %; juice 61 % vs 50 %. (b) Chicken salad: the highest attack rate in eaters, a low rate in non-eaters, and it explains 50 of 54 cases. (c) Imperfect recall, cross-contamination, secondary spread or another cause.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Attack rate = ill ÷ total in the group × 100, for eaters and non-eaters of each food.
The source has a high rate in eaters, a low rate in non-eaters, and explains most cases.
Watch out for
Choosing the food with the most ill eaters (juice, 49) without comparing with the non-eaters.
Comparing numbers of cases instead of rates when the groups differ in size.