Lesson 10: Controlling disease: hygiene, tracing, quarantine and vaccination
Why smallpox was eradicated but malaria has not been
SkillControlling disease
Worked example
Smallpox was declared eradicated in 1980, about 13 years after WHO intensified its program. Malaria still caused an estimated 263 million cases in 2023 (WHO, World malaria report 2024). Evaluate the features of the two diseases that made one program succeed and make the other so difficult.
Step 1: Hosts and reservoirs
Smallpox virus infected only humans: with no animal reservoir, once every human chain was broken it had nowhere to survive. Malaria's Plasmodium lives in humans and in Anopheles mosquitoes, which breed in billions and cannot all be controlled.
Step 2: Finding cases
Smallpox caused a distinctive rash in almost everyone infected, and people were most infectious after it appeared, so every case could be found and isolated. Malaria infections can be mild or symptomless in people with partial immunity, who remain a source for mosquitoes.
Step 3: Vaccines and immunity
The smallpox vaccine was cheap, heat-stable (freeze-dried), given in one dose with a bifurcated needle and gave long-lasting immunity, so ring vaccination around each case stopped spread. Malaria vaccines (RTS,S, R21) give partial, waning protection and need several doses; natural immunity to malaria is incomplete.
Step 4: Pathogen change
Smallpox virus varied little. Plasmodium has evolved resistance to antimalarial drugs and mosquitoes to insecticides.
Step 5: Judgement
Smallpox had every feature that makes eradication feasible: one host, visible cases, an effective stable vaccine and a stable pathogen. Malaria has none of them, so its control depends on reducing transmission (bed nets, spraying, treatment) and it can be eliminated only country by country, as Australia was certified in 1981.
Answer
Smallpox infected only humans, every case was visible, and a cheap heat-stable vaccine gave lasting immunity, so surveillance and ring vaccination ended it. Malaria has a mosquito vector, symptomless carriers, only partly effective vaccines and drug and insecticide resistance, so it can be controlled and eliminated locally but not yet eradicated.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare on the same features: hosts, ease of finding cases, vaccine, how much the pathogen changes.
"Evaluate" needs a judgement at the end, supported by the comparison.
Watch out for
Giving only the history (dates) without explaining why the biology mattered.
Saying malaria is caused by a virus or bacterium. Plasmodium is a protist.